Quote:
Originally Posted by stillerfan
we need chat if for no other reason than to call out the morons that make a bet with nothing in a check down situation only to have the short stack survive because the other guy has to fold
Not positive. But I believe that telling a player that they need to check it down in that spot is pretty iffy. It's way too similar to saying "next time, we need to check it down" which ends up being even more inadvertent/ignorant-colluder like.
you can "soft-collude" against a short-stack meaning that you check it down without talking about it or pre-planning it with the other player, etc. But to tell a guy at the table, "you idiot. Check it down in that spot!" to me is very much tantamount to informing him how you will both play it the next time.
There are some grey areas in there that can kind of go either way as to whether it's allowable or not.
Of course, by not allowing chat at all, you avoid even approaching that grey area thankfully. Good decision by Lock here to not allow the chat!