I am going to try to make this my final post on the matter. With the exception of potential pictures and text conversations. I am currently withholding those because Andrew is threatening me with a lawsuit. I will be saving them for a potential court date.
The property manager has been called and the carpet damage is being assessed. I am currently on their timeline and at the mercy of their company of choice.
Andrew will be paid his deposit back minus all reasonable damages. There is a chance the damages exceed the $725, and I am wondering if Andrew is willing to pay me the extra he owes me if that happens. I do not expect this to be cheap. I expect Andrew's answer to be something along the lines of : There is no way it will cost that much. :
That being the case, are you willing to pay me the extra money if I can prove it legitimately did cost more than $725 total?
also sick brag about your reg-date.
I didn't brag about my reg date. You continue to misread information. I bragged about my length of service to poker players in this community. It's something I am proud of. I compared my length of service to your reg-date. Here is a brag about my reg date...My 2p2 registration date is actually 2/10/2004. You were 16 years old. The Jake is a profile I was instructed to make when I bought space in the inaugural Commercial marketplace. I haven't used my old profile since.
i even found a number for a carpet cleaner which i sent to you.
I have no record of this. I challenge you to provide proof you sent this to me. How did you send it? Text? facebook? email? mail? 2p2 pm?
I look forward to your response.
i was perfectly happy to spend some of my deposit on an EXPERT cleaner to remove the stain. since presumably my deposit was in the bank it wouldn't have been a big deal to withdraw some and pay the cleaner no?
A professional cleaner was hired. We have discussed this. This has been mentioned in previous posts. Why do you persist to ignore this fact and continue to suggest that a carpet cleaner was not used?
as per jake's request i have attempted to reach him over email since the last text message where he's made it clear that he isn't willing to communicate over text. seems he isn't willing to communicate over email either (i asked him via email about 24 hours ago for the landlord's contact information). so i'll ask via 2p2 if he could PM me it to me
I received an email on Fri, May 24, 2013 at 7:56 AM. I was busy responding to your 2p2 post and didnt see it till the evening after being up for 36+ hours straight. You continue to make false and exaggerated claims about how I am handling this. At the 16 hour mark, you claim it had been nearly 24 hours. I responded to your email on Sat, May 25, 2013 at 8:44 AM. That is almost 24 hours, and a perfectly reasonable response time.
since he also suggested i take him to court, i have contacted an attorney and need the landlord's information in order to pursue this matter. NV state law entitles me to up to 2x the security deposit if it is not paid back within 30 days.
I didn't suggest it, you threatened it. I welcomed it. I still welcome it. I am confident you will not win the case beyond getting what I am already offering. I know some of you disagree, but not all information has been shared on this thread, and I can not release that information until this potential lawsuit has been quashed. At best you will get money back minus the damages,
which I am already willing to do without a lawsuit. I feel confident that any judge will see my actions as having acted in good faith, and not award you extra damages.
------------------
About these email conversations...
------------------
He has requested the property manager's contact information, and quoted NV state law.
Here is my response.
Quote:
To Andrew Kagan
Thank you for emailing me as I have requested.
At this time I will not be giving you the property manager or home owner's contact information, but I will be looking into whether or not I have to by law. I am sure that at the very least the law dictates I have a few days to answer your request. I do not believe your request to be valid. You were never on the lease. You stayed with us for a little over a month. You were not even month to month, your departure time was set when you moved in. You were allowed to stay with us, and you did pay for the time you stayed with us. I am not sure how the law would interpret your status as a legal tenant. I feel at best you would be considered a sublet.
Neither the property manager nor the the homeowner has any record of your brief stay with us. The only thing the information could possibly do for you is get us in trouble with them. This is not a solution to your problem, and seems more like revenge. Your problem is with me, and I would like you to direct any legal matters at me. Please leave the other roommates in the house alone. People live here, and they have done you no wrong. I do not even live at the house. If you try to contact the property manager or home owner you will cause damage to eight people living in the house and none to me. I doubt this will be favorable for you in any way. You can't win a case vs. them. I doubt the 2p2 community will favor this kind of action either. If you have to sue someone, sue me.
I urge you to reconsider your pending lawsuit. It will take place in small claims court, and I feel confident I can prove that I have acted in good faith. You would probably get a judgment for $725 minus legitimate damages you caused to the house. I am already willing to provide this for you. If you feel that you have suffered more damages, then by all means, it is your right to pursue me in court. I have come to realize that I made a mistake in treating the situation like this. You were not cooperating with me, and I should have instead cooperated with you despite having reservations. I have now taken the proper steps to meet you where you wanted me.
I have called the property manager and asked about the carpet stain. He is going to asses the damage and give me a bill for the carpet. I will get you an itemized list of what you owe and subtract it from the $725 and pay you the remainder.
Do you have any questions or suggestions regarding the repayment of anything I owe you? If your only correspondence with me is going to be hostile or legal action then please contact me certified mail.
Do not text me any more. Do not call me.
Jason Curran
Some of his responses
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Kagan
I just want my deposit back. If you fail to give it to me and the tenants whom you assist are adversely affected by me recovering it that is entirely YOUR fault for creating this scenario for them not mine.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Kagan
Even if 2p2 gets mad at me for following this up in court (note: I think everyone who's read the thread agrees I'm owed the security deposit minus itemization) it isn't important to me and I just want to recover what is owed. I'm happy to give updates in the thread or whatever and let people make their own judgement Also it is really dumb to think that I'm that worried about what 2p2 thinks though I believe they're on my side...I am going to law school in the fall and won't be a fulltime poker player after that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Kagan
All of my actions within that community have been 100% honest
To Andrew: Answer my challenge in this thread. It is only one example of you being less than 100% honest.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Kagan
Also I am not screwing over anyone; you are screwing yourself/me over by dragging this out. And I guess according to you you are screwing over the tenants at Big Creek Court if you aren't able to resolve this.....
I'm asking you not to drag innocent people into this because of your problem with me. I am doing everything I can to fix this situation now. I thought this was settled begrudgingly months ago when I put the $300 into escrow.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Andrew Kagan
Just settle the matter in a way that's satisfactory and timely (full itemization, etc.) and I'll drop the matter.
I believe it is clear that I am currently fixing the problem I have just promised you exactly this.
i will be bumping this thread every few days with updates re: my deposit and legal action until the matter is settled.
I believe that this thread getting bumped for this purpose is becoming unreasonable. You have already made your concerns known. I welcome any feedback positive or negative, but keeping the thread going on every thing that happens is just drama. If you must post updates about the legal action, I suggest you talk to the moderators and find a more appropriate place. If they suggest you post here, then post here.