Quote:
Originally Posted by MikeStarr View Post
All you have to do is start tracking every hand you play from the SB that is fairly questionable (and I include J7s in there). Do that for a few 100 hours and make your decision whether or not to tighten up from the SB. My opinion is that almost everyone plays too many hands from the SB...including J7s.
The whole "Im getting 8:1" argument is complete hogwash. If you dont play it from UTG, youre going to find it hard to convince me to play it from the SB.You're in even worse position. The biggest differences are its costing you $3 instead of $5 (not much of a difference) and you're pretty sure you're not going to have to call a raise, but you're still going to be in lousy position with a garbage hand.
You can bet that's not a recipe for winning.
wat. I don't mean to be a dick, but this whole post is nonsense.
I like MS posts and thread (generally), but I'm firmly going with BBB on this one, that was my exact reaction when I read the MS post above.
Haven't followed the whole "completing from SB" discussion, but for me it depends on:
The players who have already limped into the pot (ie are they fish?)
The post flop aggression of the big blind
My post flop edge (over the players already in)
there is a logic here...as a rule, in any environment I want to play loads of hands with fish in them. Fish make mistakes post flop all the live long day which makes spots which are totally unprofitable against regs, easily profitable against fish. Limping is the work of fish (mostly), so w/o an aggressive reg behind, I'm wanting in the pot and a cheap completion to see a cheap flop in a hand with fish in it is basically my Nirvana. I'm going way wider than J7s and I couldn't give a monkeys about position and/or pot odds, i just want in a fishy pot with a speculative hand. I also know where the fold button is and i don't often bluff fish, so it's not like there are going to be any hards choices once i'm in the pot.
I do this all day long at 50nlz (where there are tons of easily identifiable limping fish) so i would assume it would be equally profitable in the live environment?????
with the usual, I'm not a live player caveat (and also, I'm not interested in p1ssing contest or being a dick either...just sharing my view)
edit, just checked (since someone mentioned tracking) using the above strat I am +30bb/100 for SB completes in 172 spots over the last 22K hands (10nlz, 25nlz, 50nlz). Typically that is everything that I consider playable and don't want to ISO raise with (roughly KTo to 35o...OMC rules
)
Last edited by Fatboy54; 10-24-2017 at 08:21 AM.