Quote:
Originally Posted by DumbosTrunk
Not a whole lot to report the past couple uneventful sessions. Tonight at 5-card a dealer announced a stuck-heaps-rec-player's untabled hand that he was holding up to his face but had not yet tabled (the dealer was seated directly to the player's right and apparently peeked over and saw the hand). I had tabled my entire hand (AA) and was all in. She ignored my cards and just read his (again, untabled) hole cards as the winning hand - "we've got clubs over here." I complained at the table and to the floor afterwards and sat out the rest of her down. Obviously if the player didn't know he had rivered a backdoor flush and mucked I would have won. That's pretty much it. The rest of the session was white noise. I think I may be stuck around $400 this month so far.
Actually as long as the dealer sees the cards at showdown it's in play. If the dealer saw a winning hand and the player folded it that would be wrong to not say anything. Do you have any dealer training?
Now if the dealer said something without seeing the cards that would be different. Or if another player chimed in that would be inappropriate. I can understand you being upset here because you don't understand the proper protocols of poker but rest assured you are incorrect in this scenario and the dealer did not act improperly.
If the player had mucked a winning flush that the dealer saw you would not have won. It is the dealer's job to award the pot to the winning hand. It is childish for anyone to sit out for any particular dealer. I always laugh at those people.
The dealer has an obligation to award the pot to the winning hand. Period.
You made yourself look bad in this instance. Be aware of that.
Quote:
Originally Posted by gobbledygeek
I accidentally violated the OPTAH rule myself last session out and felt quite bad about it. Three people are all-in and there's a side pot. Main pot is claimed by a hand that isn't involved in the side pot. Noobish dude sees the tabled hand which he obviously can't beat (but isn't involved in his side pot) and gets up to leave. I think he's forgetting he's got side pot winnings still on the table (and hasn't busted out like he thought he has) and say "dude, you've still got the side pot"). As soon as I speak out I realize my mistake in that he hasn't tabled his hand yet. He then tables his hand to collect the side pot. Whoops, my bad. Dealer really should have reprimanded me but most dealers are clueless in this spot. Losing side pot guy was another noob and had no idea how out-of-line I accidentally was.
GcluelessOPTAHnoobG
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kelvis
I don't think this is out of line at all, in fact you probably should have said there was a sidepot. According to protocol the player contesting the main pot shouldn't even turn his cards over yet and the dealer should announce that the showdown is for the sidepot first. Since the dealer apparently failed in conducting proper showdown I think you should step in and ensure that players are aware when they are eligible for pots. This is not the same as the player seeing a hand that beats him in the sidepot, deciding he can't beat it and mucking which would be his own decision.
I'd argue this is pretty much the same as telling the dealer player 1 has a flush when both hands went to showdown and nobody saw it. In this case the player was thrown off by the player that shouldn't have showed his hand yet and a dealer that had no clue how the game works, I think not saying anything would be the bad position.
+1. Telling a player there is a side pot does not violate the one player per hand rule. I always tell people there's a side pot whenever someone tables a winning hand for the main pot. Nothing wrong with that.