Quote:
Originally Posted by Petrucci
I know your post wasnt directly headed against me Johnny, but from my experience and also my honest opinion: 20+ buyin downswings seems to be incredibly rare in live low stakes poker from proven long term winning players. Ive played in alot of different conditions and logged plenty of hours both in homegames,underground games,private games and casinos. 100 BB cap games, and very deepstacked games where 1000 BB pots happens several times each game.
GG says his biggest downswing is like 10 buyins or less for more than 3K hours played. I have logged more than 2K hours and havent had a downswing bigger than 8 buyins. My friend i often play with have logged over 2K hours and havent had a downswing bigger than around 6 buyins.
Well this is kind of my point. Last night I started out a 1/3 session down a quick $1200 (400 BB's) within the first 30 minutes. Was it running bad or playing bad or the grey area in between which makes analyzing a downswing nearly impossible when you try to parse decisions vs. a player's range vs. their actual holding.
My second hand at the table: $485 effective (1/3) - limp, super lucky guy who just hit the bad beat opens for $15 LP, LAG losing reg I have history with calls BTN, I 3! A
A
to $70 from the SB, limpers fold and other two call. Flop ($210) T
T
2
, SPR is ~2x. I am pot committed. I cbet $105, fold, LAG raises to $250 and I jam knowing he likes to raise paired boards with air, and will raise over pairs and flush draws on this board and I block the two remaining ATs combos while not blocking the A
flush draws. He has T
9
and holds up. Stuck a quick $500 (167 BB's).
Rebuy $500. Open/call a 3! from the LAG with 99 multiway, miss my set and he shows QQ. Less than an orbit later ($475) I open K
Q
for $15 in EP, three calls and our LAG bumps it up to $75. BB rec cold calls and I call hoping for a caller or two behind so I can commit on any flop I connect with since the SPR will be so low. Two folds behind and the luckbox bad beat jackpot winner calls on the BTN. Flop ($325) K
8
3
. SPR is 1.2x. As good a flop as I can hope for. BB jams for $250. I rejam for $400. Luckbox rejams for $800. PFR LAG folds. Turn 2
River 8
. BB shows J
7
, BTN shows A
5
and scoops a ~$1400 pot. Stuck a quick $1000 (333 BB's).
Less than an orbit later the LAG and luckbox badbeat winner GII preflop KK vs. AA, KK opens, AA 3!'s, KK 4!'s, AA shoves $1000 and LAG doesn't think long before calling it off (this is always AA, even in this game, but he's a bad LAG and couldn't resist calling). AA holds up naturally and the luckbox is sitting on a $2500+ stack.
A few hands later 3 people limp and I raise KQo (no clubs) to $25 from the BB. Two callers including our resident big stack. Flop ($75) Q
9
6
, I bet $50, lucky charms calls, Turn ($175) 8
, I bet $100. Villain calls. River ($375) J
. Great now I lose to absolutely everything. I check and villain checks behind AQ and scoops the pot. Stuck a quick $1200 (400 BB's).
So did I play bad or run bad? Hand 1 I had reads on my villain and played against his range and he happened to have one of the nutted combos he could have. But I was pot committed so I was GII regardless.
Hand 2 I GII as a 60/40 favorite and lost.
Hand 3 I was behind the whole way but was playing my hand against the likely range that villain could have and he happened to have better hand (and limped AQ on the BTN rather than raised). I managed to grind out the rest of the night and turned it into a -$100 (33 BB's) loss which is a hell of an outcome after such a horrendous start to the night.
So if over 2000 hours you've never experienced a greater than 6-8 BI (600-800 BB's) downswing and I am already stuck 400 BB's in 30-45 minutes then we must be playing in widly different games or we have vastly different ideas of what a downswing means.