Had an interesting hand take place last night vs a mid 30s Asian girl who is an ABC Level 1 player with no concept of raise sizing, pot odds, or relative strength vs absolute strength
She plays by the book and raises exactly 3 x the amount no matter the situation.
Case in point, Hero is in BB with 8
5
, effective stacks $800, villain covers. We are the two big stacks at the table, everyone else is at $200 - $400.
UTG straddles for $10, UTG+1 calls, MP calls, LP calls, V in CO raises to $30, I call from BB, everyone else calls, 6-way action.
Flop($180) K
2
6
Hero chks, (body language of all villains seem weak) chks around to V who bets $40, folds to Hero who makes it $115, folds around to V who tank calls.
Turn($410) 2
Hero bets $200, V tanks and says, "You have KQ?" and calls
River($810) 3
Hero goes all-in for $470-ish, V sonic boom fist pump insta-snap calls and jumps up from her seat and slams down (in her mind) the stone cold nuts!!!!!
Hero turns over 8
5
and the look of dejection is just all over her face. She says, "But I raised $30 preflop, how could you call with 8
5
, I thought you had AK or KQ!" She almost looks like she wants to cry and the entire table starts talking about how its an easy fold on turn for her but then I jump to her defense saying, "No, I could be bluffing there, I bluffed earlier, its a good call because I would play KQ that exact same way, yada yada yada...(FFS when will people stop berating fish)"
Analysis.
In her mind, poker is SUPPOSED to be played a certain way, you raise 3 x when you have AK, AA, KK, QQ and if you have TPTK or an overpair then you have a really strong hand no matter what the board is. She had zero ability to think beyond level 1 nor access the situation in terms of absolute strength vs relative strength. The fact that I'm shipping $800 on a flush paired board never enters her mind. All she thinks is "I have AA, AA is the best hand!!!!"
Also wanted to point out that there is always the possibility we value own ourselves. I put her range as AK, A
Q
, AA, KK. So about 30% of the time in this spot I value own myself. However, the other 70%-ish of the time I stack her. The problem I see many thinking players have is they often lose value in these sorts of situations thinking, "What if V has the nuts!!!!"
We have to be cognizant of what type of villain we are up against. Against a nit, I'm never making this play because a nit is never calling with a hand I beat. But a fish or donk that doesn't understand relative strength vs absolute strength, we can shove these types of hands for max value...
Anyways, her A
A
was a super easy fold in this spot.