Quote:
Talking about poker at the table makes the recreational fish either uncomfortable or play better and both of those are bad.
It is costing you money and it is a huge leak.
I hear people say this all the time, but I can't think of any case in which I saw people at a table react to a poker conversation in either of those two ways.
<shrug> Not disagreeing exactly, just wondering whether the conventional wisdom behind your statement isn't somewhat overstating things.
Super Bowl Sunday there was a fairly obnoxious young gun at my table that I had decided I was going to needle. Just because he was irritating. One comment I made to him was when he limp reraised with KK, I asked him whether it was 2006 on his side of the table. This started a conversation about limp reraising (with more needling from me), and that caused the guy sitting next to him to LRR AA and QQ when he picked them up in back to back hands in the next orbit. It was pretty funny.
So, I dunno; when making fun of a bad play causes other players to make that same bad play, I start to wonder about the conventional wisdom.
Don't get me wrong--I'm all for not giving up edges. I just don't see any evidence on a day to day basis that you give up an edge by talking poker at the table.