Quote:
Originally Posted by Noobie Newbertson
I think it's really important for beginning players to be wary of blanket rules. Poker is a game of adjustments and making less mistakes than your opponents. You want to figure out how your opponents are playing and then figure out a strategy to exploit them. I don't think that having rigid 3bet ranges from the button or whatever is a great idea. While the guidelines may (or may not) be vaguely accurate it makes novices think about the game incorrectly.
You shouldn't be thinking: I've got AQs OTB and MP3 opened so I'm 3betting. You should be considering stack sizes, players in the blinds, what you think the OR's range is, how he'll react to your 3b with each portion of his range, our equity in each situation, how you think he'll play post, etc etc. There's no chart that could ever accurately account for all of the factors that should go into your decision. That's why you rarely see good players making starting hand charts for cash games even though many novices ask for them.
I think points 2 and 3 are very very villain dependent and saying that they're generally true is one thing but the most important aspect is paying attention to your opponents and adjusting to their play. If you have some set range of hands for your opponents in your head and never adjust then that's bad.
I think instead of saying that most nits do this with that hand you should simply say that you should always pay attention to every hand (even the ones your not in), take note of every hand that's shown down, and continue to construct and edit individual player profiles based on how they played. Some nits flat AA.
I think you made some really good points in this post. I definitely understand how "adaptability" is the key in hand ranges, and being one step ahead of your opponents. Obviously TAG/LAG players have completely different ranges for Raising/Calling/3betting/4betting etc.
I still think tho in Live SSNL poker, you should have an idea of what "range" your opponent should have based on what player type you have given him. This may not be a fixed range saying if villain raises or 3bets he only has these hands, but putting him on a larger range given his tendencies.
This is definitely a great start to the thread everyone. Maybe we can get into some situations/scenarios which will help everyone tremendously and understand all the points we have been talking about.