Villian 1: $500 stack; UTG+3. Guy in his mid-30s. Not anybody I've ever seen before, just someone at the casino after work having a good time. He's been at the table for an hour or two, but I've honestly not picked up much on his play. He hasn't gotten out of line much, and I'm not sure if he's gone to many showdowns. Doesn't really seem super-tight, just more interested in the baseball game and hasn't picked up many hands.

Villian 2: $300 stack; MP2. Older guy (in his 60s probably). Likes to bump it up pre-flop, but plays pretty straight forward post flop. He and I have bumped heads a couple of times in the last 30 minutes. Both times he bet on the flop and I raised him out of the pot. I had him beat both times, but I didn't show or confirm/deny anything.

Hero: $820 stack; button. I'm in my late 20s and have been pretty active at the table. I got almost all of my chips from a guy who kept calling down every street in a few different pots with top pair/no kicker hands. That guy has left the table and is not in this hand. I've shown a couple of bluffs in the 4 hours I've been at the table, but I don't think anyone believes I'm out of line.

Button Straddle
Hero is dealt Q5
4 folds, Villian 1 calls, MP1 calls, Villian 2 raises to $20, 2 folds, Hero calls, Villian 1 calls, 1 fold.

Flop (~$65): A K 9
Villian 1 checks, Villian 2 checks, Hero checks

Turn (~$65): A K 9 7
Villian 1 checks, Villian 2 bets $50, Hero raises to $125, Villian 1 raises to $250, Villian 2 folds, Hero???

Where's the big decision?

1) Don't straddle
2) Fold PF
3) You turned the second nuts. Shove after his raise.