Quote:
Originally Posted by steamypile
It's interesting because I have mixed feelings about it. I have been recruiting for a lot of consulting/internal strategy type jobs and I have a little blurb about poker at the bottom of my resume under additional, right next to avid snowboarder and some volunteer activities. I am actually somewhat torn with having it there, and have had some people say it's meh or is at best neutral, and others say it's great to show some outside interests and demonstrates some sort of strategic thinking.
I am, of course, not looking at any real technical jobs here. Additionally, a case interview prep coach thought it was cool to have, and a few career counselors have also said it's an intriguing bit that can make me more memorable and generate conversation so it's good to have. Still unsure about it though, and both your stories are definitely sobering. I have had a bunch of interviews in the last 2 weeks during recruiting season (disclosure, I am getting an MBA) so it's certainly not keeping me from ALL interviews, although whether it's been hurting or helping I can't really quantify. Most of the time I assume it isn't even noticed.
The problem is that a hiring manager does not have to have a valid reason to decline you. All in all the negatives out way the positives. Very few hiring managers are going to know what positive things playing poker brings to the table. More are going to have a tilted view of poker (read... seedy, underworld, crime, violence, sin, dishonest, untrustworthy, etc, etc) and that is something to just avoid. There are too many resumes to jobs these days, all it takes in one thing and into the wrong pile it goes.
I did a short stint in a c store job in college, was on graveyard shift (easiest to steal). The manager was great and loved me, until he found out I played poker and that was my primary source of income. He freaked. Lucky for me he was a honorable man and didn't invent a reason to fire me on the spot. A couple days later I walked in with a roll in my pocket that was larger than the biggest day of sales the store had ever had, flopped on his desk... "This is the money I play poker with, poker is my business. Your piddly ass sales in this store isn't worth my time to take. But I need this job for the benefits." We were on good terms after that, and he actually learned a little and played a little in one of our smaller games after that.