Set up:
Table is 2/4 but max buy-in is $300
Players are generally weak and will play just about anything at anytime.
HJ is tight old man.
Hero: MP $320
HJ: ~$300
BB: ~ $210
UTG: ~ $200
PF: Hand goes limp UTG, I raise MP with 97c to $16
Hi-jack calls, BB and UTG call {Pot $66}
Flop: 4
5
9
BB check, UTG checks, I bet $40. Hi-jack calls, BB calls, UTG calls. {Pot $226}
Turn: 9
BB check, UTG check, I check, Hi-jack checks
River: 4
BB bets $70 leaving about $100 behind. UTG folds, I shove, Hi-jack folds and BB tank folds.
My question is obviously with my check on the turn. I should have shoved right? I didn't want to bet "small" and just be called by the gravy train, so thought I'd check for pot control. Once HJ checked the turn behind me I realized he had an over pair, and I was concerned he could have a better 9 till then.
Anyway, I feel I might've chickened out of the correct play. Thoughts?