V1 ~ $400 - he hasn't been at the table long and I unfortunately don't remember how he got his stack. I kind of had the feeling that he was going to try to be table captain.
V2 ~$50 - he's on his 3rd or 4th $100 buy in. Seems relatively tight but he's either running horrible or just a donator. I'd lean toward the latter.
Hero covers
V2 limps in MP, Hero completes 76o in the SB, V1 check in the BB
Flop $6 - 9
7
6
Hero $6, call, call
Turn $24 - 9
7
6
6
Hero $15, V1 $60, V2 all in for less, Hero calls
River $150 main $36 side
9
7
6
6
3
Hero check, V1 all in
We're beat by 99, 77 and 96 all of which are possible though V might raise 99 or 77 pre.
Villain over bet shoves the pot on a blank card and the impression is that he thinks his hand is good. Can we fold? Do we really want to?