Results: I didn't take too long to shove. Player in between folds, villain calls with 8
7
and (I'll leave this blank sine it doesn't matter. I had a little over 30% equity on the flop).
As is often the case, I'm still not sure if I made a mistake. Some posters said shove, some said just call, some said fold.
Case for shoving: If villain is raise/calling with 109, then shoving is obviously right, as proved by my EV equation. Wouldn't even nits usually raise this hand though? Not all nits are the same, and it seems to me only the tightest of nits would not raise top two pair. What's top two pair afraid of anyway on this flop? My range is usually just top pair or a limped overpair when I lead flop. Did I have enough information to categorize villain as one of those nits who would only raise sets and straights on this flop?
Case for folding: IF villain is only raising sets and straights, then the EV of shoving is quite negative, over $150 in the red. On the other hand, IF villain has a wider range, the EV of shoving is positive but less than $100 EV.
Would villain really have not played 109 the same way? If he had 87o in his range, he would also be seeing the flop with all combos of 109o.