Hey TPTK77,
I thought this was an interesting hand, so I gave the V some ranges pre, on the flop, turn and river and calculated EV for a river call. I'm probably wrong half a dozen times. If there is anything you think I should modify range wise, let me know and I'll recalculate.
The description of the V seems like you might not have a clear idea of how he plays post-flop? The tight/aggro description seems to be opposite of each other? Is there something I'm missing there?
I suspect he's most likely a typical 1/3 player who limp calls insanely wide and overvalues one pair + draw and top pair+ no kicker. He will "value bet" in ways that just seem super spewy.
So, with those assumptions in mind. Here's the range construction I have for him.
Preflop:
66-22, ATs-A2s, KJs-K2s, Q8s+, J8s+, T7s+, 96s+, 85s+, 74s+, 64s+, 54s, 43s, AQo-A9o, KTo+, QTo+, J8o+, T8o+, 98o, 87o, 76o
Flop
66-22, ATs, A6s-A2s, KJs, K6s-K2s, QJs, JTs, T7s, 97s-96s, 86s, 74s+, 64s+, 54s, 43s, AQo-ATo, KTo+, QTo+, JTo, 76o
Assuming V Continues w/ pair + any draw + some 2 overs
Turn range:
66-22, A6s, KJs, QJs, JTs, 76s, 64s+, 54s, 43s, AJo, KJo, QJo, JTo, 76o
Assuming V clicks back with pair + draw, weird Jx and stronger hands.
River range:
66, 33-22, QJs, 64s+, 54s, 43s, AJo, QJo
Assuming V bets bigger here with some overvalued Jx, some 2 pair, and continues to bluff with the low pair + draw hands to get you off AA, KK, AK, TT, 99, 88, 77 etc.
Against river range, we have 44% equity.
EV = $65 for a call.
I don't hate a fold, don't hate a call. Absolutely comes down to the V and if you think he's overvalued some of those Jx hands. If this is the case, then we should definitely lean towards a call.