Table is fairly loose-passive with lots of limpers pre-flop and when there is a raise many call with pots often going 5 or 6 way.
V1 ($250): 45ish heavy set Mexican guy with bandana. Horrible player. Prides himself on "not being scared and letting people bet him off of pots" even though there's not much aggression at the table. When he bets himself it seems like he's just pushing buttons as he's bet a bunch in spots where no worse hand would call and most better hands would call.
V2 ($200): 35ish white reg, mediocre LAG for 1/2, probably playing 65% of hands, raising pre-flop 20% of the time and straddles whenever possible. In the 1.5 hours he and I have been at the table together, I've seen him 3-bet 4 or 5 times (only hands he showed down were TT and AA). Seems to view hero somewhere between TAG and nitty.
V3 ($500): 35ish phillino reg, fairly loose passive pre-flop, seen him play his draws aggressively post-flop. Not a horrible player but not great either.
Hero ($375): 30ish white guy, I've raised pre-flop more than the average person at the table and taken some pots down with c-bets, but haven't continued to many turns and rivers and I haven't had to show many hands. Been a bit card dead and most of the table probably sees me as TAG/nit.
OTTH... Hero raises $10 UTG w/ J
J
V3 calls UTG+1, folds to V1 in SB who calls, V2 in BB raises to $45.
Is it too nitty to fold here? Based on the way the table and these players have played, V3 will probably call (and def not raise) and V1 will almost certainly call. If I had to range V2, I'd say 99+, AK, AQs.