Quote:
Originally Posted by Jon_locke
I think the more plausible explanation is that the people that would really punish their mistakes are playing bigger, so the preflop mistakes don't cost nearly as much as they would elsewhere. For example, you open 56s utg and get cold called in 4 spots; not that bad vs you open 56s utg get 3 bet and have to play heads up vs a very strong range vs guy that plays really good.
There's probably a lot of truth to that.
Having said that, it may also be that we are talking about two slightly different players. Your player is a LAG who is too LAGGy or not sufficiently skilled at adjusting to table conditions.
My player is fishier than that pre-flop. For instance, the people I think about might cold-call a UTG raise from a decent player with Q8 suited or 98 offsuit. And then play it reasonably enough postflop. Or maybe after 3 limpers he will call any two in the cut-off, even complete trash like 72 offsuit. This is why I say he might have absorbed some no limit strategy-- because these plays might make a bit more sense in a deep stack no limit game where you really can profit from trading mistakes a lot more than you can in limit.