Quote:
Originally Posted by Bodypull
Excellent post. And thanks for sharing your outputs. No worries, I'm happy to have co-existent solutions. One reason I'm developing this tool is because I NEED IT and it doesn't exist yet...
One question before we start comparing: are your results taking only 2-way all-ins in consideration?
Yep, I'm only considering 2-way all-ins. I class a 2-way all-in as either:
A) We put all our chips in the pot on our first action (push or call all-in). Whatever the action was before or after, it's still a 2-way all-in so long as only one opponent remains when we leave the pre-flop stage (all dead bets from other players are properly handled, so there can be raises and folds from other players, eg: UTG raises, we push, BB calls, UTG folds, etc are all handled correctly...).
B) We make a call for less than our total stack and there are no non-all-in players left (ie: this can't handle BTN pushing and us just calling from SB as BB isn't all-in already, but it can handle say BTN push all-in, SB fold and we call in BB).
(I can fix these to handle any 2-way all-in where we are all-in with a single a opponent as we leave the pre-flop stage, but atm that's what it does and that's why I'm getting slightly less data-points per SNG...).
I also take ties into account and have three separate outcomes for every all-in (ie: we lose, we win, we tie).
I think a much easier way will be to compare outputs for the same HH files. What I've done it output a ".csv" file which has a row for every all-in, eg:
Code:
HandNumber, P_Outcome1,ExpPrizeEquity1,ExpChipEquity1, P_Outcome2,ExpPrizeEquity2,ExpChipEquity2, P_Outcome3,ExpPrizeEquity3,ExpChipEquity3, ExpPrizeEquity,ActPrizeEquity,PrizeEquityDiff, ExpChipEquity,ActChipEquity,ChipEquityDiff, CumSumPrizeEquityDiff%,CumSumChipEquityDiff%, CumMeanPLoseDiff%
6438834895, 0.578456,0.266926,6180, 0.416829,0,0, 0.0047147,0.158965,3090, 0.155155,0.266926,0.111772, 3589.43,6180,2590.57, 11.1772,259057, -41.6829
6438844098, 0.636412,0.387597,10880, 0.359697,0.314306,7580, 0.00389023,0.352481,9230, 0.361098,0.387597,0.0264992, 9686.58,10880,1193.42, 13.8271,378399, -38.8263
6438865986, 0.351842,0.42351,12660, 0.643951,0.334212,7380, 0.00420647,0.380797,10020, 0.365827,0.334212,-0.0316146, 9248.83,7380,-1868.83, 10.6656,191516, -14.0159
When I post the exe you should just be able to run it on your own hands and compare my output with yours.
EDIT: Made my example ".csv" file easier to understand - I was using the term "EV" when I meant "Equity" and since dollar equity is measured in terms of "% of prize pool", it seems clearer to measure chip equity in terms of "our total chips" rather than "our chips gained/lost since start of hand".
Juk
Last edited by jukofyork; 01-24-2008 at 04:58 PM.