Hello
Since i was always too lazy to program endless amounts of Note Caddy Stats myself your work was really a blessing! I respect what you did there and have been a Fan of your statistical approach since watching your Bluefire Videos years ago.
But i ran into some Issues:
1. I rearrenged and edited a lot of Stuff, i dont mind to overload my HUD with numbers like you do, so prioritze numbers over badges. I rearranged or did create many Pop Ups myself and did attach many Note Caddy Pop Ups (like Range Graphs and Scatters) to my Pop Ups. But after Exporting and reimporting my HUD all my costumly attached Note Caddy Pop Ups are gone and i have to repeat this work. How did you manage to make these Pop Ups stick in yout HUD? When i reimport your HUD all the Note Caddy Pop Ups are still attached to the Pop Ups...
2. I got a minor Issues with Syntax of some Stats, in detail with Bets vs missed Cbets. BetvmissedCbet in Position (PFR is OOP) is easy to find but i have issues to identify which exact situation the stats reflect with BetsvmissedCbet when OOP or Bets after XX XX Bet for example.
A BetvmissedCbet when OOP can first occur on the Turn since PFR has to check back the Flop. PT3 defines these Situations as Probe Bets. Which Definition reflect these situations?
Secondly im not sure how u did define "Stab" but a Stab in my syntax can at first occur on the Turn when PFR is OOP (or on River when PFR is IP). Since a stab isnt a Bet vs a missed Cbet in my world but an attempted steal on an unconested Pot. Thats means PFR hast to Check 2 times before PFC can attempt a stab, if PFR just checks once its an BetvmissedCbet or a Probe Bet.
In short which exact situations do your Stab Stats represent?
To sum this up, if im not just too stupid to see how u defined those situations you should come up with a new syntax for those definitions in your next update, to make it easier for people to rearrange your stats suiting their desires.
For Example:
There are Bets vs missed Cbets and Stabs, which are Steals on unconetested Pots. You could call a BetvmissedCbetOOP (PFR is IP) a Probe Bet like PT4 does and come up with a new shortcut for BetvmissedCbetIP (PFR is OOP) like a "Stup Bet" or anything what you think fits or maybe PT4 already defined it since i stopped using it.
Additonally there are "Stabs" at uncontested Pots which require PFR to Check 2 Times(or 3) and you could define Stabs as StabOOP and StabIP.
This would open up new possibilites to easily define ceartain situations. For example a Delayed Cbet is well defined by now and everybody knows it occurs on the Turn after Flop goes x/x. A Delayed Turn Stup Bet Defintion could easily identify a situation where a Cbet is Called on the Flop ; PFR doesnt Cbet Turn and PFC doesnt bet vs the missed Cbet - Turn goes x/x ; PFR checks River again and PFC Bets now ; [ B/C X/X X/B ] These situations arent well defined and when Edges get smaller and smaller you want these situations to be represented in your Stats and clearly and easily defined.
Poker language created a lot of new vocabluary to represent certain situations and since Stats get more and more advanced i dont see any reason to stop the definition process and you seem very suited to come up with new solutions which could open up new stats and Edges.
3. Why didnt you include Barrel River after Flop Raise and Turn Bet Stats for example? The lower you go in stakes the more generic people are in certain spots and even if you dont get a very reliable sample for those rare spots you should include stats like this in your package. Its quite possible to have a large amount of Hands from generic mass grinders in your Database and at least some indications on their tendencies could help a lot with decisions regarding bluff catchers or thin value etc
Your Package gets stronger with big databases but still it seems like you neglected some stats which only get helpful with a big database. This seems counterintuitive to me. If you dont see fit for them in your included HUDs you could at least offer those in the -All format for people who would like to include them in their HUD/Pop Ups.
Im sorry for the wall of text and i hope my english skills were strong enough to make myself clear.
Last edited by Rakkazzar; 07-30-2015 at 10:18 PM.