Quote:
Originally Posted by Nofx Fan
why would you make it your concern what others buy or don't buy?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sect7G
I think number 2 is fair if it's done with tact. The last thing we want is investors to make too many bad investments and lose money and give up on the marketplace.
I never thought of it that way, I didn't know there were that many uninformed investors. Very tough spot, it's like trying to protect people from themselves.
I have to admit, I just read a thread (was trying to find the one he mentioned) about some guy from SC and it's a mess, and misleading. I can see why frustration would set in and this would need to be done.
With that said this opens a can of worms. I just saw a guy(well known successful player) sell out quick at 35 percent MU for the scoop ME. I guess that's an excepted value because no one said anything. Also, has there ever been a case where potential investors were talked out of buying and the horse then ships something? What happens in that case?
I thought I read a thread on this debate somewhere. I'll try to find it, but I thought it was a good debate and most people came to an agreement, witch was basically... If the person is being dishonest or not open then it was decided saying so in his thread is fine, and IMO should be done. If everything was on the up and up but seasoned investors didn't think it was a great value, it was not to be said in the thread but rather spoken by not investing in the person.
I'm obv rambling now, but again, looking forward to more people's opinions on this.