Quote:
Originally Posted by Ungoliant
I agree that some of the absolute best episodes are MotWs, but it's not exactly fair to the mythology to do an episode-by-episode ranking of all episodes because the whole point of those was that they were open-ended pieces of one long story, so they often aren't complete or don't have particularly satisfying resolutions when viewed individually. It was more a case of the whole being greater than the sum of the parts imo.
Also, in fairness, about 2/3rds of the 200+ episodes fall into the MotW category, so while everyone always brings up the great ones like Squeeze, Jose Chung, Clyde Bruckman, Bad Blood, etc, there were a lot of clunkers in there too. Anyone remember Space, Teso dos Bichos, Alpha, or Teliko? If so, it's probably not for good reasons. There's definitely a selection bias when people remember their favorites and talk about how great MotWs were. The peak ones may have been the best episodes in the series, but I'd still say the average myth arc episode was better than the average MotW. Totally agree that the series wouldn't have worked as well without the combination of the two though.
I'd agree with this.
MOTW episodes had all the peaks and all the duds. Most of the myth arc episodes seemed more relevant to the show, where as the MOTW episodes seemed more relevant to the characters.
I wasn't dissing the myth arc episodes, just saying I don't get the "LOL MOTW episodes, they were just filler" mentality when they were, as you say, at least 2/3 of the show, have most if not all of the top ten shows for the series (definitely all of the bottom ten episodes) and, at least in my view, helped round out the characters a great deal more than just focusing on the myth arc could have done.