Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Under The Dome Under The Dome

07-02-2013 , 01:11 PM
Lead character is compelling. Lady reporter is a decent character. Some other good characters along with a few really bad ones especially the loser boyfriend.

I like that the 2nd ep answered a few of the questions raised in the first episode.

I'm in.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 12:44 PM
Pilot was like "ok this can get really cool", ep 2 was "nope it wont"

I'll keep watching tho, as long as they don't kill the very few cool characters
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 12:51 PM
I expected this to suffer from most of the same problems that The Walking Dead, Terra Nova, Falling Skies and Revolution suffered from. The first eight minutes of the pilot seemed to confirm this but I was given hope with the introduction of the lead guy and subsequent dome-related bovine gore. Now though, I'm thinking it will mostly suffer from the same flaws with perhaps a few flaws from convoluted directionless shows such as Heroes and Lost as well. Hurray!

I'll keep watching, if there's anything all the shows I've mentioned have in common it's this: a premise with the potential to be dynamite. Heroes occasionally lived up to that potential, Lost and TWD too to begin with (even if the latter was only for two episodes), perhaps this show can too (but I'm not holding my breath).
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 01:47 PM
Haven't watched yet, but value your opinions. Would you guys say that this is better or worse than Revolution or Terra Nova?
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 01:55 PM
I would say it's better than Revolution for sure, but then I held Revolution in pretty low regard almost immediately. I would say it's better than Terra Nova but Terra Nova's pilot had a cool dystopian future and dinosaurs so it's not cut and dry yet. I think it's better than Terra Nova was after the pilot.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 02:30 PM
It's hard to compare it to those two honestly, but it's probably a better show. Hard to say this early. Revolution is pretty terrible and Terra Nova might actually have been better than it.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 03:26 PM
Way too many stupid human tricks in the second episode. Also, seems we're going to have a trend of someone dying at the end of every episode. And in this case it was someone just introduced this episode. Which is just great storytelling.

Meh, sticking around but I dunno how much longer.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 03:28 PM
Thanks guys, will give it a try. Wasn't comparing it to those shows in terms of style or plot, just quality, since those are 2 relatively recent new shows that I've tried and been disappointed by.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 03:57 PM
There is potential, I mean cutting off a town from the outside cant not have potential, but if they go too soap opera-ish making it about the ****ty relationships of random characters instead of the potentially interesting of whether people would come together in a crisis or fall apart trying to exploit one another and how the two conflicting dynamics would inevitably have to coexist the show could be pretty meh. Definitely not clear which way they will go yet.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 04:01 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by [Phill]
There is potential, I mean cutting off a town from the outside cant not have potential, but if they go too soap opera-ish making it about the ****ty relationships of random characters instead of the potentially interesting of whether people would come together in a crisis or fall apart trying to exploit one another and how the two conflicting dynamics would inevitably have to coexist the show could be pretty meh. Definitely not clear which way they will go yet.
TWD, Terra Nova, Revolution and Falling Skies all chose, to a greater or lesser extent, the soap opera route. Given the success of TWD, Revolution and Falling Skies I'm not hopeful that they won't go that route here. I wish they wouldn't, but I think they will.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 09:14 PM
Is this a mini-series or is there any possibility of a 2nd season?

I usually have a rule about waiting until the 2nd season to watch a new show. I've had too many shows get canceled on me. I really want to watch this though.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 09:16 PM
If the ratings continue they'll be milking this cow for all it's worth, even if they have to stitch the halves of the cow back together.

Yes, there's the possibility of further seasons.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 09:36 PM
Okay, thanks for the quick reply. I was told it was a mini-series but that's what I figured. When ratings are good, nothing is ever going to end.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 09:39 PM
Damn straight. Even shows that are billed as mini-series have the possibility of further seasons if they do well. This, however, was not billed as a mini-series as far as I know. Perhaps some called it that because it's a summer show and so won't go past 13 episodes this season (so 'mini' compared to a full order or 22/24 episodes) and it was just ordered straight up as a batch of 13 episodes without even a pilot.
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 11:28 PM
Right, not a mini-series. The plan is for up to three seasons if the ratings hold, and they had another huge week for episode 2

CBS: "Under the Dome" (11.5 million, 7.3/12)

The next closest for the night was

ABC: "The Bachelorette" (6.4 million, 4.5/7)

So yeah, more than likely this is a 3 season run minimum
Under The Dome Quote
07-03-2013 , 11:31 PM
I guess I will give it a shot.

Going to leave this thread until I"m caught up, thanks again guys.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 01:18 AM
A +1000 page book potentially getting turned into a 3 season show will have several "filler" episodes. Be prepared for them.

If they didn't want to milk it for all it's worth they could make a solid 13 episode show and cover all the important/interesting/exciting stuff in the book.

edit: I read a quote from SK the other day about The Dark Tower. He said he'd really like to see movies made about Roland as an adult and TV shows about him as a kid. That might be how Netflix will be involved.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 02:33 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by I_AM_EVIL
A +1000 page book potentially getting turned into a 3 season show will have several "filler" episodes. Be prepared for them.

If they didn't want to milk it for all it's worth they could make a solid 13 episode show and cover all the important/interesting/exciting stuff in the book.

edit: I read a quote from SK the other day about The Dark Tower. He said he'd really like to see movies made about Roland as an adult and TV shows about him as a kid. That might be how Netflix will be involved.
I heard they will change the ending of the book to make the story longer. And cause it sucks. Jussaying.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 08:40 AM
Thats not the only thing that will be changed. The books is mostly jus being used as an outline ans for character names. Everything else is free to be altered at the screenplay writers whim
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 12:24 PM
Caught up and watched it, better than awful, but nothing compelling. Barbie guy (hate the nickname), reporter girl, math kid, hot girl, police chick, and Breaking Bad councilman all good characters. Psycho boyfriend, reverend, black mom and white daughter bad characters.

Like everyone else, would prefer more focus on Dome stuff and military/scientist intervention rather than relationships. They're putting in a decent amount of town conflict vs getting along though. Did it kinda crappily with the fire + crazy policeman, but they'll probably get there eventually, since they're showing the generator/lack of fuel & supplies stuff, the stores of propane, and Barbie buying cigs to stockpile & trade later.

Would really prefer to have zero book stuff discussed itt, or at the very least, to have it all in spoilers (even if it's not a true spoiler but just a comparison), clearly marked with Book Spoilers Below. Thanks guys.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 03:26 PM
watched today, it will most likely be awful.

loled at the fire starting scene. He kicked the bin, at which point I thought he wanted to actually set the house of fire, but no, he just wanted to set it aside.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 03:51 PM
Yeah I thought he was intentionally trying to burn the house down that was so bad. I'm kinda on the fence and leaning toward taking this off my dvr. I'll give it another episode.
Under The Dome Quote
07-04-2013 , 07:36 PM
The jealous boyfriend is such a cartoon, one of the most absurd characters I can remember.

The reverend burning the house down was a really bad scene. So the writers are saying that is the best they can do?

Hate the lesbian family, the daughter is offputting.

I will continue to watch if these get less screen time.

edit - the cop shooting at the dome had zero chance of hitting that cop.
Under The Dome Quote
07-06-2013 , 06:19 PM
It's clear that most people in this thread don't seem to understand what summer network TV is. This show is nothing spectacular, but it's miles ahead of both Revolution and Terra Nova in basic structure and tone. I was worried after the first episode that it would get boring, and they wouldn't have new or interesting problems to solve. I'm not saying a fire is one of those, but I left that episode with more confidence that the show won't be a stagnating pile of fly drawing matter. I was also extremely worried this show would be very cheesy, and it hasn't done that for me yet. I think I'm mostly won over by the exceptionally high quality sound mix, which makes the show enjoyable to watch. Cut the Junior story out, and I'd be relatively happy overall with how the show is, but that ain't gonna happen.

Book "spoilers" below, and only time I'll mention the book, as I started reading it this week:

Spoiler:
I think it's a huge error in judgment to add this whole Angie/Junior story thing. It's the worst thing about the show, and it's completely contrived as the Angie character was killed in literally her first interaction with Junior in the book. That was a very disturbing part of the beginning of the book, so I can understand why they changed it, sort of. However, as with most King villains, there's mental imbalance caused by some external factor running it (in Junior's case in the book, supposedly migraine headaches and a very bad mean streak), as opposed to the Junior of the show just being a super psycho jealous nut job. Because they needed to contrive that, they had to completely change the backstory of the Barbie character, which is also a mistake, in my opinion. It makes no sense that they made him an outsider, as opposed to a homegrown product that went outside. I'm guessing the two kids are basically playing the narrator, because in the set up, neither of them were introduced, from what I remember, though I haven't gotten through the entire set up yet. Last book point is that I would have loved to have seen them do the opening practically verbatim to the book, but it would have been harder for them to do than what they did, which was also quite effective in its own way.
Under The Dome Quote
07-06-2013 , 06:23 PM
You don't think it's cheesy? I do...

Persons Unknown was a similar kind of concept aired during the summer and I thought that was way better. Less cheesy, less soap opera, more originality and a lot more suspense.
Under The Dome Quote

      
m