Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread

03-22-2019 , 05:34 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Schneids
So I assume Aubry doesn't get to carry her idol and extra vote with her to extinction island, to potentially bring back to the game if she got back in?
What if she didnt bring them to tribal and left them buried in the sand? If she got back in the game could she retrieve them?
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 05:40 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Soncy
Now can we say we find Reem and Wendy annoying without getting attacked, or do we need to also throw Keith and Wardog in there for equality's sake?
All 4 are horrendous.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 07:29 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Double Down
I'm not saying they should have played it differently, just that that display of loyalty for each other might come back to bite them in the ass. The irony is that they're not that loyal to each other. Possibly if they had gotten rid of one of their own last night, the members of the other tribe would be more open to working with them post merge.

Of course, anything goes after the merge and we suddenly see people make all kinds of moves, so it's not like they're dead in the water at all.
S
I'm not sure the show of solidarity is a problem given they aren't solid. They are more than willing to turn on each other. Anyone who might want to align with some of them will be able to find that out in a conversation. Dave targeted Kelley in early going, Wardog was ready to turn on Lauren, and all of them were considering getting rid of Wardog.

It seems more likely the fact that Kelley and Dave are returning players will be the thing that hurts this group given the climate of the other tribe towards returning players.

Wardog's bossy attitude not going to go over well either.

In other matters, Joe needs to try the wounded bird attack (see Tyson). Natch won't work.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 10:23 PM
It all depends on who returns from Extinction. If Rick or Aubry come back then David, Kelley and Joe should be able to come together and get at least a temporary majority with Lauren, Wardog and Aurora.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 10:31 PM
Joey Amazing is a perfect example of a guy who is actually too good at this game. Incredible at challenges, carries his tribe on his back, liked by everyone, does a ton of work around camp. You'd think this would be a recipe for winning survivor but sadly for him it's not.

The edit definitely had me thinking he was gone this week. But no, instead he takes over on the puzzle and saves the day. Again.

Obvious he’s gone as soon as he loses a challenge. Dude needs to find 3 idols to have a chance.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 10:47 PM
Reem would like to speak to the manager
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 10:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Symbioticse
I think they look worse because we see more of them on Extinction. Reality is it's hard to come back with as big reputations as David and Kelley have, David specifically is dogging it in every challenge and surviving. Kelley also seemed to have complete control by the end of her swap tribe and was the only one not being targeted.
.
Do you feel David is trying to be worthless, rather than just is worthless in challenges?
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-22-2019 , 11:47 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by revots33
Joey Amazing is a perfect example of a guy who is actually too good at this game.

Obvious he’s gone as soon as he loses a challenge. Dude needs to find 3 idols to have a chance.
Someone who constantly needs to win immunity or they'll be voted out cannot be described as too good at this game.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 12:43 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by revots33
Joey Amazing is a perfect example of a guy who is actually too good at this game. Incredible at challenges, carries his tribe on his back, liked by everyone, does a ton of work around camp. You'd think this would be a recipe for winning survivor but sadly for him it's not.

The edit definitely had me thinking he was gone this week. But no, instead he takes over on the puzzle and saves the day. Again.

Obvious he’s gone as soon as he loses a challenge. Dude needs to find 3 idols to have a chance.
He's good at one aspect of the game but not really good socially at convincing people to do stuff nor strategically. There was a stat I saw on twitter, dude has literally not voted someone out of this game since his first season.

David and Wentworth are better and no don't think David is intentionally bad at challenges he's just awful generally but that makes his survival of 5/6 of the first few tribals that much more impressive contrast that to Joe who should be more useful to any tribe who would've been voted out.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 12:57 AM
Dave won 3 individual challenges in his season
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 02:46 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by King~of~Diamonds
Reem would like to speak to the manager
Reem definitely seems like the kind of woman that calls the cops on a black guy walking around in her neighborhood.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 10:11 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by catangod
I don't understand Aubry's thinking. She floats an idea of Her + Victoria + Wendy voting off a man. Wendy stares back at her blankly. This should be warning signs for her. She is a total moron but should be jumping at this opportunity to form the 3 girls alliance. Then Aubry just assumes "lol Wendy" and predicts a 4-1 vote off. Underestimated her tribemates. Gotta give some credit to Victoria, she did a great sell job, great plays.
I don't think she necessarily underestimated, she overestimated Wendy. Aubry should 100% have realized that Wendy not willing to commit is weird. I think Wendy didn't want to lie/backstab someone. This might not be true, but it seems like Aubry did not even consider this. Stupid move, though I think people itt are being too harsh. She should have used her idol, but you can make a fair case on why not using it was good, too.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Soncy
Victoria obviously awesome. Thread seems to approve. Woman hating thread theory debunked.

Now can we say we find Reem and Wendy annoying without getting attacked, or do we need to also throw Keith and Wardog in there for equality's sake?

Also, lol at the tribe who decided it would be a good idea to vote Chris off going on a challenge losing streak and complaining about it. That wasn't foreseeable?
To be fair I kind of enjoyed Wendy this episode when you just think of her as someone who is there to do everything except for play the game. I also liked her reaction when given the choice to play further.
(She still is one of my least favorite players ever for the stupid chicken crap)

Quote:
Originally Posted by Double Down
So even though I think the 4 of them played it well last night, making the read that the other 3 wouldn't put their game on the line for Wendy, they may have done some damage to themselves for the rest of the game. Here's why:

They're going to be at an 8-4 disadvantage at the merge. Usually when one team is at such a disadvantage, they have two options: 1. (The more favorable option) Try to find cracks within the majority and bring some of them over. If this doesn't seem like it's going to work and the writing is on the wall, then: 2. Be willing to turn against their own.

By holding so strong together at tribal last night, it's going to be hard to convince anyone in the majority alliance to flip over because the majority will know that the 4 are so tight that whoever joins them will be on the bottom of that tribe. I could potentially see Joe being tempted but it seems like he's preferring to stay strong with his originals. I suppose if Aubrey hadn't gone home, it would be enticing for her and Joe to flip over some there are two vulnerable returnees on the other side. But if it's just him, not enough incentive.

If I'm in the majority 8, I'm letting my tribe mates know that after that display of loyalty last night, it's imperative to just pagong them out of the game, perhaps sparing whichever one is left as a decoy to blindside Joe or other threats on my own team.

I'm not saying they should have played it differently, just that that display of loyalty for each other might come back to bite them in the ass. The irony is that they're not that loyal to each other. Possibly if they had gotten rid of one of their own last night, the members of the other tribe would be more open to working with them post merge.

Of course, anything goes after the merge and we suddenly see people make all kinds of moves, so it's not like they're dead in the water at all.
S
Meh this makes a lot of assumptions. You make a fair point if Wendy was not part of any core group and disliked by everyone. I see the revote more as a choice between "going to rocks to drag along a goat" or "voting out Wendy."

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mojo56
The guy that calls himself 'Wardog' is an athletic embarrassment. To say that he threw 'like a girl' would be a disservice to females everywhere. Lauren showed him how to do it until she ran out of gas. I would have liked to Wentworth step up but 'Wardog' jumped in front of her. What a douche. Too bad the merge is coming because it seems like the tribe is finally coming to the realization that 'Wardog' is a poser who needs to get the boot.
He's Tony lacking everything that made Tony awesome. I wanted to like him but I've given up this week. He's useless and I'm going to guess post-merge he's going to be voted out quickly for being too bossy.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Symbioticse
He's good at one aspect of the game but not really good socially at convincing people to do stuff nor strategically. There was a stat I saw on twitter, dude has literally not voted someone out of this game since his first season.

David and Wentworth are better and no don't think David is intentionally bad at challenges he's just awful generally but that makes his survival of 5/6 of the first few tribals that much more impressive contrast that to Joe who should be more useful to any tribe who would've been voted out.
I agree but imo he's really improved this season and he has been trying stuff that he didn't before, and could have helped him a lot in hist 1st run.
He might have been terrible before, but you got to realize he is in the most difficult position out of everyone this season wrt playing the social/strategic game.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 10:12 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by revots33
Joey Amazing is a perfect example of a guy who is actually too good at this game. Incredible at challenges, carries his tribe on his back, liked by everyone, does a ton of work around camp. You'd think this would be a recipe for winning survivor but sadly for him it's not.
This is a perfect example of someone that doesn't understand the game.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 09:36 PM
Keith taking off with the map made me laugh really hard for some reason. Coupled with the other people’s reaction. It brought me more joy than anything on this season
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 09:44 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Didace
This is a perfect example of someone that doesn't understand the game.
this is a perfect example of someone that doesn't understand what he just quoted
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-23-2019 , 10:58 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by King~of~Diamonds
Keith taking off with the map made me laugh really hard for some reason. Coupled with the other people’s reaction. It brought me more joy than anything on this season
Keith definitely has some redeeming qualities as far as making some good Survivor TV. Wendy seems like a mostly nice person who likes adventure, but she's not my cup of tea--I'm not going to go into it. Reem seems pretty horrific, but the wtf moments in small doses are almost worth it. Mostly just to see these other poor saps having to try to deal with her. Will anyone choose to raise the sail just to get away from Reem? Watching Wardog click buttons has the most entertaining value to me. He's trying to play. Other people are trying to play with him. He thinks he's good, but he's not.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-24-2019 , 08:27 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by King~of~Diamonds
Keith taking off with the map made me laugh really hard for some reason. Coupled with the other people’s reaction. It brought me more joy than anything on this season
pretty funny that he had a massive head start on them and still failed to find the advantage. classic keith.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-24-2019 , 09:18 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Soncy
Keith definitely has some redeeming qualities as far as making some good Survivor TV. Wendy seems like a mostly nice person who likes adventure, but she's not my cup of tea--I'm not going to go into it. Reem seems pretty horrific, but the wtf moments in small doses are almost worth it. Mostly just to see these other poor saps having to try to deal with her. Will anyone choose to raise the sail just to get away from Reem? Watching Wardog click buttons has the most entertaining value to me. He's trying to play. Other people are trying to play with him. He thinks he's good, but he's not.
It's funny that people compared Wardog to Tony only because of his craziness at the beginning and trying to make moves fast. Tony had enough sense to realize he was overplaying and toned it down quickly once he had a solid alliance. If Wardog tones it down post merge he has a legit shot to go far IMO but no way he will win.

Although let's all acknowledge that the only reason Tony won is because Woo took him to FTC by choice, which is probably one of the biggest idiot moves in Survivor History besides Diamond Lil.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-24-2019 , 06:59 PM
Quote:
Originally Posted by ponyboy
It's funny that people compared Wardog to Tony only because of his craziness at the beginning and trying to make moves fast. Tony had enough sense to realize he was overplaying and toned it down quickly once he had a solid alliance. If Wardog tones it down post merge he has a legit shot to go far IMO but no way he will win.

Although let's all acknowledge that the only reason Tony won is because Woo took him to FTC by choice, which is probably one of the biggest idiot moves in Survivor History besides Diamond Lil.
Let's not forget the OG for this type of move, Colby. Not only did he do it first, I'm pretty sure he threw away the most EV, which is no easy feat.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-24-2019 , 10:13 PM
Aubry was blind sided and outplayed but the deck was stacked against her. If she uses her idol and stays around to the merge with 0 allies (previous vote being 4-1 against her) she is very close to drawing dead. If she took Victoria at her word and voted off Wendy saving her 2 advantages she rolls into the merge with very high win equity. You can't force people to like you, stupid format with 2 returning players mixed in each tribe, makes for boring game play.

Not Aubry's biggest fan/white knight just think there was reason to go out the way she did.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-25-2019 , 12:04 AM
Pretty much all of Aubrey's confessionals are cringe central. Also, did she say "donut powers activate" or something super terrible? UGH don't even remind me.

Was that slide puzzle in the second episode's immunity challenge made of only 6 pieces? I thought I saw 2 columns of three... That's really not difficult at all, especially since the final image was a square. These people should know better. David says "here it comes" and then mashes every button til the game is over.

SAD

Redhead is not hot, sorry. GTFO with that. She might be smart and crafty but duping Aubrey isn't exactly a 5 star accomplishment. Still appreciate her on the show at the end of the day.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-25-2019 , 05:07 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by moo buckets
Pretty much all of Aubrey's confessionals are cringe central. Also, did she say "donut powers activate" or something super terrible? UGH don't even remind me.

Was that slide puzzle in the second episode's immunity challenge made of only 6 pieces? I thought I saw 2 columns of three... That's really not difficult at all, especially since the final image was a square. These people should know better. David says "here it comes" and then mashes every button til the game is over.

SAD

Redhead is not hot, sorry. GTFO with that. She might be smart and crafty but duping Aubrey isn't exactly a 5 star accomplishment. Still appreciate her on the show at the end of the day.
I predict that she's gonna look pretty foxy all dolled up st the reunion.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-25-2019 , 10:38 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Melkerson
Let's not forget the OG for this type of move, Colby. Not only did he do it first, I'm pretty sure he threw away the most EV, which is no easy feat.
True, but this was also in a different era of Survivor where people thought if you played the best game physically and were honorable to your people you would get jury votes. Not so much any more.
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-27-2019 , 08:16 PM
You’ve got to be kidding me. No way Jeff gives them a chance to stay at edge of extinction if Aubrey isn’t among them. NO WAY
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote
03-27-2019 , 08:20 PM
Lol so this is what, Aubrey's 5th shot at this game??
Survivor S38: Edge of Extinction Main Thread Quote

      
m