Sepinwall and Fienberg with 30+ minutes talking about The Shield finale as the best series finale ever on
this week's podcast. I showed the series to my girlfriend earlier this year and it was just as good as the first time around. When watching the series live, I was frustrated with S2 and S3 but I think they played better watching them in a more condensed time frame. There certainly were some big moments in S3 with Aceveda's slurp slurp, Dutch strangling the pussy, Tavon going through the windshield and Lem burning the money. I still think the money train robbery could have been carried out in a more interesting way with better planning shown, but I look back at it more fondly knowing the awesomeness it sets in motion.
The thing that most shocked me is that Antwon Mitchell appears much later in the series than I remembered, not until S4. I thought he was in S2 or at least S3. I also didn't remember that Whitaker was in S6. S6 as a whole played better than I remember. In my mind it was just the bridge season between the amazing S5 and S7. There wasn't much closure at the end which does give it that feeling that it's not an enclosed season, but there were some great moments with Billings setting up Dutch, Shane accidentally greenlighting Vic and Ronnie, then taking Vic's family hostage to ambush the assassin. Vic finding out Shane killed Lem, and Kavanaugh completely losing it.
Some guest stars through the series that I wouldn't have known when it originally aired: Kristen Bell in S2, Clark Gregg on The Shield before Agents of SHIELD playing the cuddler rapist in S3, and in S6 there was Ken Jeong and the Armenian mob boss daughter being the assassin woman from The Bridge.