Quote:
Originally Posted by the_snail03
Immortality isn't never ageing, it's never dying.
I understand that. But I think we're kind of splitting hairs.
Jacob didn't die of natural causes, ever. And he also couldn't be killed by the other person who inhabited the Island with him(most of the time). That's not technically immortal, but it's pretty close, and still makes the question about how Hurley is already dead a reasonable one.