Quote:
Originally Posted by kingofcool
How is this show doing ratings wise? Anyone else worried about this being on USA rather than netflix/hbo or similar?
It's low rated, but good enough to barely get renewed on cable for Live+Same Day. It does significantly better in DVR ratings, but I think that's all just PR babble from the cable channels saying "see people still watch us", since they've had massive audience erosion in the last 3 years as DVR has widened. Only FX is potentially using DVR numbers as a guide, as they've renewed a few shows that are pathetically low rated (though they tend to only do this for shows they like since there's no true precedent by them).
The good news for Mr. Robot was that USA was so excited by the show that they renewed it before it aired. That's basically never happened for them. However, I would say they're likely extremely disappointed by how it's performed. Most shows that start out with ratings like this on USA get new showrunners/creative directions for season 2 (because they want a season 3). This show is unique in that it would completely undermine the show to go a completely different direction. To me, the USA direction is the whole Angela b-storyline where she was trying to get Colby. They want to see more of that and less of Elliot's weirdness. Eventually they'll converge, but the more standard USA TV show vibe is in the Angela stuff. If there's a massive expansion in her storyline in season 2, it would kind of bear that idea out.
Quote:
Originally Posted by midas
I don't think any TV series has ever dealt with an unreliable narrator which leaves so many questions and challenges (ie what is real?).
You're right about that, because networks and most cable networks don't want to touch that kind of show with a ten foot pole. It's extremely polarizing, and polarizing usually means a small audience or a rapidly leaving audience. It's a huge risk. Because Esmail wasn't really established, there are probably some lower budgets being used. However, NYC is a budget buster that's rarely been used on cable, so I'm not really sure what they're thinking about it. As I said before, this property would run forever (if they wanted) on Syfy. It's a pretty big risk for USA, because I'd say it has no better than a 50/50 chance of retaining a lot of its audience from the first season. This isn't a grow between seasons type of show no matter what you might hear from others.
Quote:
I hope the writer has a finite number or seasons/episodes in mind with a well thought out plot outline. Making it up as you go won't work here, its way too complex.
He's planning it to be somewhere between 30 and 40 hours. He knows how it ends. Everything else is in play.
Quote:
Breaking Bad's first season was only 7 episodes and averaged 1.23 MM viewers. I'm not sure the 20 somethings are even onboard with this show yet. I doesn't seem to have huge buzz.
Breaking Bad and this show are apples and oranges for numerous reasons. First, Breaking Bad was an elite show the whole way. This show is often really good, but is still way derivative of a bunch of stuff. Breaking Bad was solely about drugs and a dying man's "desire" to take care of his family with expert skills he had in a business that wasn't used to that kind of skill.
This show is about a genius computer expert with some form of schizophrenia, who is using his "powers" to do something really bad while trying to justify it without really doing anything good in the long run. Walter was an okay guy who had a lot of things happen to turn him into a bad guy. Elliot's a bad guy who thinks it's okay because some people deserve it.
Breaking Bad started out polarizing, solely because of the premise (a lot of people stayed away because of it). This show had a really interesting premise, and it's what got people in the door. As the show moves further along without developing and paying off mysteries, it becomes more of a task for the average audience to watch. Shows like this play to a very narrow audience in general, and it's done nothing (by way of the finale) that's going to make people who aren't watching it say "oh damn, I gotta watch that". Even Breaking Bad took until maybe season 4 before people started giving it a big shot. It was only really popular in its last 8 episodes. Also, ratings expectations were lower on AMC at that time. They wanted award worthy shows, and Breaking Bad was absolutely that. It wasn't a show trying for awards when it came it, it just happened. Mr. Robot seems to be "trying" for awards rather than earning them without trying. It's just so heavily borrowed that the really knowledgeable people in the Academy will have some problems with it...not to mention it's a genre show (they hate those). I'm not saying it won't break through with some nominations, but I don't think it has any better of a shot than something like Hannibal. A big positive for it over a show like Hannibal is that it's a U.S. produced show.
As has been told to me on several occasions, Emmys are about buzz. This show has buzz, but it's coming out at the worst time of the season. Everything else will have aired after this for next year's awards. Very few Emmy nominated shows are on in the summer. The biggest contenders are usually still airing in May. I'd expect Mr. Robot to be a January or February show for season 2, because it would be idiotic for them to not try to capitalize on the buzz it has built. If it's not, then they're not expecting any real awards notice for Emmys.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bbfg
I thought the creator said in an interview he has it planned out as a 4 season show
The latest interview I read said 30 to 40 hours. He thinks it would be bad beyond that. My guess is it will probably run closer to 30 hours. I wonder if that means USA will stick to 10 episode seasons to string it out longer.