Quote:
Originally Posted by EddyB66
I have no idea what I think. On one hand the evidence in the doc point to him being innocent. On the other hand the evidence I have read about point to him being guilty. On the other hand why would a guilty man spend all that time getting files, and basically becoming a lawyer if he was guilty of murder. So, I have no idea where I stand.
Let's rewind a bit on the idea of him being guilty of murder. He's stupid, but we know he's been working on that salvage yard his whole life. He's in the middle of a civil suit to the tune of 36m max damages, and he's got a girlfriend he's madly in love with who will soon be out of jail. As we've seen throughout the movie, all the man wants is a girl, his family, and a place to be himself. He's also just done an 18 year bit. Are we supposed to believe that:
-He tells everyone he's about to meet with Teresa, the girl he then kills
-That he's totally willing to jeopardize the 36m on the line in that very moment
-that rather than use the smelter on the property that he knows how to use, he just burns the body in the back yard
-that rather than crush the car beyond a trace, he's going to just hide it with branches, with blood still inside
-that in all the instances of recorded phone calls with him right after all this butchery takes place, the dude sounds super chill and madly in love with his girl who is currently serving her DUI time
-he lives on a compound with something like 3 homes side by side and like 10 people around at all times. That's the spot you kill someone? lol no.
-this is the guy you think is clever enough to sanitize a garage so completely as to not leave 1 godamn trace of brain/blood/bone anywhere in that garage? How? Not a drop? He leaves the car full of blood, but the garage full of hoarder stuff is bone dry?
I see nothing even close to a motive, in fact just the opposite. He's got all the motive in the world to NOT kill her. But in a moment of temporary insanity IF he does kill her, he's got so many better ways to hide his track, even as a red neck. Smelt the body, crush the car. And if you've somehow got that body into your car (blood etc...), you damn well don't toss the bones in some piddly burn pit behind your house like an idiot. There's forest all over the county to do that in.
It's all horse****.