I thought Hickey came across as completely insane for several episodes, but keeping it under control because he had convinced himself he was sane and was great, his whole rambling speech before the attack was pitch perfect imo, and him convincing himself he could befriend the monster through being special fit with his delusions of grandeur. If he had been too crazy it would've been hard to buy him leading the mutineers.
The one thing that came off a little forced was
And yeah the last shot was just