Quote:
Originally Posted by hotdogfallacy
It is obvious that they haven't slept with each other for a while, but that's really because he was banging Billy right in front of Margaret's face. To me it seemed like Nucky was pretty genuine trying to reconcile with Margaret as of late. That scene where he was juggling and trying to be friendly with Margaret earlier, seems to support my position. He may not care for Margaret like he used to, but her family is much more than a business relationship to him and he clearly cares about it, especially the kids.
I agree he did feel more attracted to Margaret when she sang in front of the children, and that he does care for the children. However I don't agree that he's been trying to reconcile with her, perhaps until now when he's seen her reaction to Owen's murder. He admitted to her that Billy is dead and its his fault, and I don't think he would have bothered with her too much if Billy was still around. If you think it's only been since her death that Nucky has been trying to win her over again, well then ok I guess, but I might disagree upon a 2nd viewing
Quote:
From Nucky's relationship with Billy, I learned that he was an obsessive, old creepy piece of ****, who doesn't really cares about people close to him. But I do not see it as character development, more like a revelation. It is not like he suddenly became this sort of person, it seems pretty clear that he was always a pos scumbag. This makes it even harder to care about his character, but whatever. As far as Billy's relationship with him, it seems pretty clear that he was seen as her 'sugardaddy', up until he beat up that guy and she fell in love with him for some reason.
I could not possibly disagree with this more. In nearly every scene with Billy even prior to beating up that guy, it is easily noticeable that Nucky has very strong feelings for Billy, and that she returns them. She cooks for him, shares genuine feelings, and he has a key to her apartment. He never gave her any money until the day before she died, aside from buying her some dresses
The idea that she falls in love with him only after he beats up that guy is just flat out wrong, and that is blatantly obvious to me from what I've seen of their entire relationship. I suggest you rewatch those scenes, but whatever, you are free to disagree
Quote:
Why would it believable that Nucky would not give a **** about Chalky's request? Up until now, they have seemed very close associates and it is not like Chalky was displayed as some low level officer brown-nosing Nucky, he was shown as someone in charge, whose favor it is important for Nucky to have. Chalky numerous times I believe displayed his loyalty to Nucky and Nucky before gave permission to get revenge on KKK in a very similarly divisive issue. It just seems very odd that Nucky would be flippant with Chalky all of a sudden.
He's not low level, but he's not boss level either. I'm not sure why this seems odd to you when black folk are still very low class at this time; why would Nucky care so much about his wishes when he is about to go to war? There is no guarantee that Chalky is going send all his men to follow him into battle, and we don't even know how much manpower he even commands. It's not like he was flippant or disrespectful either, he is usually a much bigger ahole to people he views as beneath him
Quote:
I really do not think I am in danger of missing anything between the lines, this is the kind of show that spells everything out for you pretty clearly. Although, it just throws out so much crap out there, that I can't blame someone for missing a thing or two.
Imo, you are missing a lot. Your analysis of Nucky/Billy's relationship is not even close to accurate. There are many scenes where missing a single facial expression at a specific moment can mean a failure in understanding a character