Quote:
Originally Posted by SMIGLET
Exactly how would you have made it any better? I thought it went down perfectly
I think if you're asking me
exactly what I'd do differently then you're missing the gist of my post. It would take a world class writer to do that scene better. To distill the motivations of a master of the universe into a manageable five minute scene is ridiculously hard.
And yet, Mad Men did it. Remember the bar scene where Conrad Hilton meets Don? That scene informed every Conrad Hilton scene that followed. Hilton was a self-made man who felt dislocated in high society, who simultaneously envied, mocked, and wanted to conquer the upper class. He appreciated hard work. He didn't like people, doubted marriages, and was religious. All these great contradictions. And the way Don charmed him was completely awesome and earned.
On Boardwalk Empire, Nucky had a smooth opening about the stock ticker. He appealed to Mellon's sense of patriotism. Then he took words out of Mean's mouth and was like, "it's the little things that stick in my craw" regarding Mellon's distillery. He offered Mellon a likely inconsequential amount of additional profit. He was polite and flattered him. Input obvious data, output: complete success!
Flattery didn't get Don far with Conrad. In fact it was never exactly clear what did work with Conrad. He was an incredibly difficult cat to skin. But we knew who Hilton was. We knew about his earnest, foolhardy plan to bring America to everywhere in the world. On this show we have not even scratched the surface of what Mellon is about. My favorite line from that scene is the very end when he says "You've brought some color to my day Mr. Thompson, and I do appreciate that." That's the master of the universe style I'm looking for. But I have my doubts that we'll ever find out what's under the hood.
Last edited by dankhank; 11-08-2012 at 06:52 PM.