I would do disgustingly vulgar things to Siobhan.

pretty much thought everyone sucked tonight. no rankings.

Lee>>all tonight imo. Regardless, Lee still wasn't very good. This season is absolutely brutal. I will watch for the train wrecks though.

You can call me whatever you want without getting reported. People on this site have thin ****ing skin

At least we avoided repeated use of the word "pitchy" tonight

lol? lee was so bad this week. him/crystal worst 2 performances this week.

Oh yeah, Kara calling Aaron out on being a virgin was hilarious also.

Even Crystal sucked. I didn't think thatt was possible. Shoulda had Mark Twain week imo.

Crystal didnt suck, but it was her most boring. This whole week was a total train wreck. Awful.

Mike is terrabad beyond belief. Among the worst in the shows history. I would honestly take Sanjia over him, or even that she bangs guy.

Moral of the story: Shania Twain was and is ****ing terrible. Celine Dion bad.

Surprised at the Siobhan love from the judges. I thought it was brutal.

Casey and Lee killed it tonight. Everyone else was kinda bleh. Oh and Siobhans performance...how did that not bring out the "very karaoke" comments? I mean come on. I have liked her every week but this was just so laughable.

i'm never shocked at the judges putting over the contestants anymore. that whole night was brutal as hell and the only one they called out on it was crystal because they are so used to her destroying the competition. i will not be shocked at the bottom three at all. no matter who they are. but i'd rather casey and mike gtfo asap.

me too, and I'm a fan of hers.

Crystal. Seems like she'd rather do what she wants than win

Siohban. Has a great high range, but doesn't sound any good at all low or medium.

Lee and Casey did a good job

Aaron's was good for him

Mike is a good (OK) singer, but not an entertainer.

Ratings after tonight

Crystal


Lee

Casey

Siohban
Mike
Aaron


I suspect a Crystal /Lee final, but if the girl voters get giddy it could be Crystal/Casey

PS. IDOL. Stop with the theme nights. Let them, sing whatever they want.

There is nothing wrong with Shania Twain. there are are lots of people who like her music. I just don't want to see theme nights about anybody.

yeah I like siohban, but it was terrible. It was a far worse karaoke version with an off pitch scream at the end. No clue what the jedges heard.

Shania also didn't seem to like siobhan's performance. From memory, she was pretty enthusiastic when they showed her after the songs and with Siobhan, she seemed to be giving it a golf clap with a fake smile.

I was really confused them using her as a category. Not nearly a big enough catalog and not enough genre mixing to make it a good choice.

shania <3 haters can gtfo!

the problem lies with the contestants not the songs. crystal gave a boring performance, lee started off poorly so that by the time he got going it already had a sour taste....with casey's performance, idk, something about it wasn't quite right. same thing with big mike. same thing with siobhan. aaron was ok this week i guess but i don't even really pay attention to / care about him. just meh. lee was probably overall the best this week and i thought it was one of his weaker performances.

What show were you guys listening to??

Shania has some decent songs and there were some good performances. Just because you don't like her music doesn't mean it's not a good choice for a theme.

Casey - one of the best performances of the season. My wife wanted to buy this right away.

Mike - I hate Mike but this was awesome. I could hear this on R&B radio immediately, it was relevant and touching.

Crystal - good performance of a meh song. But the arrangement made me think she'd be at home with Blurgrass, as well as her folk/rock vibe.

Aaron - decent but forgettable

Siobhan - not sure what the judges were seeing, but this song has to be sung with attitude and spunk, not sincerity. Wrong song for her.

Lee - the judges are high. This was awful. Started out low and pitchy then just got loud and strained. Lee's worst performance.

Siobhan going home

I wouldn't listen to Shania Twain with stolen ears but there is no denying her pop appeal.

Casey was fantastic, Mike was Mike, Aaron was ****.

One would think Siobaby had the sass to pull that song off but she was too breathy and it would help to sing on key.

God I hate Lee. Hate hate hate. **** him. Really.

i pretty much agree with this. I thought Lee was bad and the judges were like 'suck suck suck'


but i really thought Casey was good tonight.

0% chance of this

85% Mike
15% Aaron

I don't care if they want a country week. Dolly Parton theme a few seasons ago was solid. Don't think Shania Twain has enough recognizable songs. They need a bigger pool to pick from.

im not a big fan of casey but it was pretty good, and lee is just a boss he has this in the bag imo

say what you want about siobhan's performance but at least she had the balls to pick one of "those" shania songs. Didn't really seem that into it though.