to be fair, Tim has been middle of the pack the last three weeks. He's been worlds better than Aaron. Aaron has a stronger voice but he's a nerd, and he's going to sell 0 records once he goes home 6th or 7th
Tim has been better than Aaron, but Aaron sucks so for me its basically whatever. Tim will be around for a while, since thats how this show works. In a "perfect" world, the finals will be Lee vs Crystal, but I don't see that actually occurring here.
Tim is like a straight Sanjaya for me. He's got zero shot of winning and is noticeably worse than everyone else, yet for some reason he never ****ing goes. Get Tim, Aaron, and Mike out of here so the actual competition can start.
I think Tim is more like Anoop from last year. Everyone loves him, he can sing ballads pretty well, but he isn't going to win.
The point is, anyone that has a chance of winning isn't going to be affected by Tim at all. Tim is taking votes away from Crystal
no by suck i meant i dont really enjoy their voice or tone... i can still agree they are very talented though. again.... my opinion of someone doesnt equate to their actual talent.... looking forward to your predictions next week.
That's a really bad analogy. If I only think Aaron's vocals are a little better than Casey's and Casey's a much better performer, then of course I'm going to want to see Casey.
My whole point was that Archuleta's vocals were far enough better than Cook's to make up for any gap in performing ability.
my point is you are underestimating how GOOD David Cook is vocally.
i agree DA is probably better as a pure singer, but Cook is really really good.
Aside from Clay and Reuben and DA, who on Idol has more pure singing ability than David Cook? I'm not saying they don't exist, I'm just asking who you think is a better singer? I'm talking about the males only.
Some of the notes he hits at the end of ABMB is similar to Siohban, but he hits then, and the whole song is on pitch, unlike simoan.
Yeah... Mike's save was an f'ing joke and this vote was even more of a jokes event. Katie is the only one on that stage (other than maybe Lee) who could actually be a legit recording artist/pop star. Oh well. The lulz that are American Idol.
KATIE HAS A HORRIBLE SOUNding voice even if she is technically good.
Originally Posted by toohigh
glad katies gone, she's like jordin sparks but worse...simon was spot on last night calling her annoying, her performance was cringeworthy
very annoying! simon is right
Originally Posted by TheHip41
Katie's garbage and I'm pretty sure we will never hear from her or her ******ed grandma ever again
right on brotha!
Originally Posted by ThaSaltCracka
god I hate how this show is driven by votes from America's dumb ass citizenry.
Best singers left going into tonight:
The rest can gtfo imo.
But what do they do? Vote off one of the few actual good singers left. Tim being around still makes a complete mockery of this "competition".
siobhan has problems in many of her songs but if she picks the right stuff she's one of the best..... mike sucks, u coulnt pay me to listen to his crap