Casey is creeping up on Siobhan as my second favorite. Not as good as last week but good job.

casey is getting boring imo. good vocals, but he just doesn't do anything different week to week.

Casey has always been incredibly boring

crystal - all-around great performance. she is solid every week.
katie - despite ignoring adam's advice i thought her vocal was better than anyone without dreadlocks.
------------
lee - he's kinda all over the place but he takes chances and seems to be gaining confidence.
tim - gaining a lot of stock these last two weeks. i liked his performance tonight.
casey - getting bored with him. running the risk of being a one-trick pony imo. vocals are good but the guy is fading.
------------
siobhan - i hate that she's been crappy three weeks in a row. i rated her too high the last two weeks but it's becoming clear to me that she's losing stock as well.
aaron - didn't really follow adam's advice either. didn't do enough to get himself out of the hole he's in.
mike - vocal was alright, but very sleepy. didn't do enough to dig himself out of his hole either.
------------
------------
andrew - a lock to go home. this performance was terrible.

i thought andrew was actually pretty good

Agree with Titans except move Lee down a spot or two and Mike up one. Crystal was in her own class though. Nobody is close to her.

+1

i fast forward through his ****

Casey has to have one of the worst auditions ever for a finalist: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Uousps8-dg

+1

please respond yes or no. if you don't respond, it's no bet. if you don't respond, you are a puss though


also, after his performance, i'm assuming you won't give me 10 dollars and won't respond


but as always, i'm right, and really, that's enough

i'm obv watching 2 hours after everyone. how can you guys not like Michael. all he does is pick good songs and sing them well and on pitch. except for the Beatles song, he has been the first or 2nd best guy every week. I'd say there have only been a few performances by guys that come close to his top three. Casey's Jealous Man and that good one by Lee two weeks ago, that's it.

i want some


this is my song for her and I

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_QcgCSkExEI

it is my opinion that katie is by far the most marketable out of anyone this season as a recording artist. crystal has a better voice, but katie has the image.

what, you don't like chubby hippies that have kids?



crystal
michael
katie
lee
tim
siohban
casey
aaron
andrew



going home, aaron andrew

My picks

For you people saying Mike is sleepy....

When he tries to pick it up he gets himself in the bottom 3, when he sings slow songs, he has been safe. Why change it up? His singing is excellent.


Ya, I'm off the Siobhan bandwagon as well.


I thought everyone besides Andrew and Siobhan did pretty well. I liked aarons actually

Can't believe this is my first time posting ITT as I watch every week and would love to discuss it. Grunching to the last page, but it looks like I'm one of few Casey James fans. I was a big Siobhan fan for a while but her stock is going way down after being horrible two of the last three weeks.

Andrew is clearly gone (way to break the story, cstone). The producers must be happy it's double-elimination to maintain ratings/suspense about the second boot.

Crystal and Lee are the only ones who are absolutely safe, which is to say if they all gave the same performances as they did tonight and the voting was done 1000 times, I think Crystal and Lee are the only ones who would never be voted out.

Power Rankings:
Crystal
Lee
Casey
Siobhan
Aaron
Katie
Mike
Tim
Andrew


edit: a huge +1 to whoever made the cartman reference

Flip Tim and Aaron and I 100% agree with you on everything (and I'm a casey fan as well). Tim has huge momentum right now and has no shot at elimination tomorrow imo. Frankly I would be stunned if anyone other than Aaron and Andrew was eliminated. About the only drama is seeing who else is in the bottom 3 (4?).

Jesus, Siobhan's performance was puke inducing awful.

If she ever gets signed, she needs to get those chops straightened out. She looks like a shark when she opens her mouth.

Big Mike's version was sort of slow, but he did sing it well and I actually liked it quite a bit.

Also, uh... Katie's voice was all over the place. I did not like it at all.

i wouldn't be suprised if siobhan goes home tomorrow

As usual Crystal makes everyone else look like a joke.

Please GTFO of my TV forever Mike. God he is maybe my most hated contestant in the shows history.

so you loved Megan Joy and hate big Mike


interesting

You guys might honestly be some of the dumbest people I've ever seen. Most of you wouldn't recognize talent if it sat on your face.


Siobhan was BY FAR the best performance of the night, AINEC. She had a couple crappy weeks, but last week and this week were phenomenal. The start of this weeks performance was lame, but the middle-end was ridiculous.


Last week was her mad world. That performance was incredible, as was her vocal control. A bit slow, but who cares, it was perfect.


This weeks rankings


Siobhan
------
Big Mike
Crystal
----
Casey
Katie
Lee Dewyze
---------
Tim
Aaron
Andrew


Overall rankings

Crystal
Siobhan
----------
Big Mike
----------
Casey
Katie
Lee
----------
Andrew
Aaron
Tim


Based pretty much exclusively on vocals. If I had to pick personal favorites, I'm not sure who I would pick, but I dislike big mike despite ranking him high. I also like lees tone alot despite ranking him low.

My overall total rankings are about the same as you CxF except Casey over Big Mike and Aaaron over Andrew with Andrew last too.