Quote:
Originally Posted by RU18LOL
far from horrendous singing, i thought it was great. To each his own though
but the thing about singing, it's not "to each his own"
I agree you can like one person's tone more than the next. You can hate Dave Matthews but love Geddy Lee for the tone they create. However, from a singing ability standpoint, Lee wasn't good last night.
He's not awful, he's just not good. His voice is all over the place. I really believe that if David Cook was on Idol 9, Simon would not be all up on Lee's nuts. He would be saying, watch DC, that's how you do it.
Kind of like, if Crystal had been season 8, Lilly would be around still, and probably make the top 5, and everyone would be saying, omg, so original and awesome, but since Crystal is here, she looks 2nd rate and goes home 13th