Open Side Menu Go to the Top
Register
American Idol Season 9 American Idol Season 9

03-17-2010 , 01:25 AM
Siohban's performance was so epic tonight. Easily the best of the season imo.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:29 AM
yeah siobhan ***** killed it!!!!

really liked didi too.

Andrew PLEASE pick an upbeat song with some damn range. He really isn't a one trick pony.... but it sure is ridic. hard to say otherwise with his performances after chasing pavements.


how many are going home this week?
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:30 AM
just one i believe
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:31 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tiltyjoker
yeah siobhan ***** killed it!!!!

really liked didi too.

Andrew PLEASE pick an upbeat song with some damn range. He really isn't a one trick pony.... but it sure is ridic. hard to say otherwise with his performances after chasing pavements.


how many are going home this week?


1


fwiw, it's always 1 unless they lol take 13 into the top 12 so the producers get all the ppl they want in the top 12, or if it's Idol gives back and don't want to rain on that parade with goodbye tears
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:32 AM
i think garcia is going to have one more week to redeem himself then ^

not off the bandwagon yet... but it's getting kinda hard watching him fail week after week sigh
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:34 AM
my first thought when seeing him tonight was "wtf??? no guitar?? this def cannot end well"
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:35 AM
Garcia is painfully bad. I'm surprised he has any fans.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:35 AM
Garcia reminds me of Lil Rounds. Hits an early song out of the park and then stinks it up until America mercifully sends them home 4-5 weeks too late.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:41 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Machinehead
Garcia reminds me of Lil Rounds. Hits an early song out of the park and then stinks it up until America mercifully sends them home 4-5 weeks too late.


Andrew's probably is I don't see a fan base that can save him very long. He's not white, black, young, good looking, or funny.

He has a pretty good voice with no range, and you can tell he's a douchebag like Gokey, ie, no one cares if he loses. So yeah, he will be gone 10-12, because if he was capable of knocking it out of the house, he would have already
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:47 AM
there is noway he's a douchebag cmon
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:52 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
Big Mike- pretty good don't like song choice or arrangement tho 6.5/10
Didi- voice is weak at times but i was into it solid job 7/10
Casey- like the tone of his voice, seems like a cool dude 7.5/10
Lacey- she gets much better every week 7/10
Andrew- he murdered this song ugh plz stop 0/10
Katie- NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO 1/10

Tim- for the love of dog stop voting for this dude America 0/10
Siobhan- holy **** amazing best AI performance of all time wowwowowow 11/10
Lee- i mean goddamn Siobhan was GREAT. wow. wait who's this guy? 4/10
Paige- voted for her 10 times already. Siobhan, I mean. ldo. 5/10
Aaron- I SEE A LITTLE BOY I WANT HIM PAINTED BLACK 5/10
Crystal- very cool. maybe i should skip all but crystal and siobhan? 9/10

1. Siobhan
----------
2. GOD
----------
3. Crystal
----------
4. Casey
5. Lacey
6. Didi
7. Big Mike
----------
8. Paige
9. Lee
10. Aaron
----------
11. Katie
12. Tim
13. that one guy
+ Siobhan

the only thing I have to add is wtf does Simon keep saying Lee has an incredible voice? this is demonstrably not so.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:58 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by amplify
+ Siobhan

the only thing I have to add is wtf does Simon keep saying Lee has an incredible voice? this is demonstrably not so.

you watch, once Lee makes the top 10, Simon is gonna drop the usuckgtfo hammer on him


also, of course andrew is a douche. the guy thinks he's amazing, and he clearly thought he would coast through to the top 8, then start working.
the fact he's tweeting he is holding back and now he's going to WOW us, then gives us garbage like Genie in a Bottle.

You can tell just by his expression he is, just like Crystal, just like Gokey
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 01:59 AM
mike: pretty solid. should be safe. has good stage presence, unlike some.
didi: I hate this bitch, but she was best of night IMO.
lacy brown: i hate this bitch also, and am happy that she was fairly bad.
casy james: fml so safe. he should be crushing, but he way too safe.
katie stevens: she hit her notes. impressive. still not great.
garcia: pretty awful for him. i would not be surprised if ppl got sick of him and he is cut.
magnus: I hated it. but i like her. last week was amazing, i did not get it this week though.
lee: i taught it was mostly flawless technically, which is good for him b/c he has been very pitchy before. but it was fairly tame and forgettable.
urban: lol, gtfo
aaron kelly: wow, this kid is prolly the weakest vocally, but he nailed it. top 3 of night. well done.
miles: decent. thought she would suck this week.
bowersox: standard. flawless. sexy. marry me plz. I am waiting for he to own really hard. she has been like 8/10 imo.

cut: lacy and miles

also, im very happy i have money against garcia. now, if any1 wants more action, i'd bet 1:1 that shioban does not win.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:02 AM
Crystal/Siobhan are ~58% to win on intrade.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:05 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by amplify
the only thing I have to add is wtf does Simon keep saying Lee has an incredible voice?
do you hear his voice? the sound of it is really nice and commercial. casy james also has those moments.

shioban, sings well, but the actual sound of her voice is not as attractive to me. I think this is what simon is talking about, not skill, but sound.

lee butchers every second note, so i dont get why simon praises him. but he does have a great sounding voice imo.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:09 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by vixticator
Crystal/Siobhan are ~58% to win on intrade.
yeah i wasn't thinking about realistic odds. is there a page on intrade i can see odds? i only see stuff that looks like stock prices.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:21 AM
No direct link that I know of just go to intrade click on markets and go to entertainment and AI.

edit: Oh. Those numbers are out of 100 i.e. 100% chance of winning (the winner). If the price is at 39 like Crystal then 39% chance of winning according to the market.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:25 AM
Siobhan was epic, first really sick performance of the season imo. Crystal and Didi also were really good, and I think all three are better than any of the guys.

I still don't get the hype with Mike. Simon's comment about the corniness was spot on. He just feels like a lame bar singer or something to me, not a recording artist. Casey's stupid puppy dog smile like he thinks he's the **** while he's playing the guitar is immensely tilting, and I think he's someone who would just look silly doing what he does outside of Idol.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:28 AM
I like Lee. He's not amazing or anything, but I can think of at least 6(Tim, Aaron, Paige, Katie, Andrew, Lacey) people I'd rather see go before him.

Also, did anyone think it was awkward when Kara referred to Randy + Ellen as "the guys" twice?
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:28 AM
imo it wasn't really fair. i mean she did paint it black. no one was going to touch her tonight.

Last edited by TITANSMASH; 03-17-2010 at 02:29 AM. Reason: fff kara
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 02:50 AM
Quote:
Originally Posted by Machinehead
when Kara referred
no clue, been fast forwarding through her yapping all season long
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 03:11 AM
Siobhan picks the best songs. I think she is very aware of what she can crush.


I get that people are getting tired of Kara's advice, but I think she was dead on what she said to Andrew. The song was suppose to have a hardness that I don't think he is capable of. There are certain songs you can't sissify.


Ellen is pretty hilarious.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 03:21 AM
I think when Kara isn't blabbering on about making a record or being on the radio or whatever she gives good advice and knows what she's talking about. Simon apparently thinks it is ok to come out and just sing any song you like while entirely ignoring the content of the lyrics or anything. I mean, wtf.
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 03:33 AM
the way i see the judges is:

randy; prolly knows more about music (not singing) than the rest of the judges. overall useless
ellen: really nice and funny, mostly useless
kara: knows most about singing, gives best advice on singing. i hate her though. idk why, she just tilts me
simon: focuses more on the "image". prolly knows best what sells, and therefor his opinion is most important if you wanna make $$$
American Idol Season 9 Quote
03-17-2010 , 03:46 AM
I also think Simon is right sometimes when he disagrees with Kara's advice. Sometimes it isn't fair.

For instance, in the same circumstance, when she tells a 16 year old the song isn't believable coming from them, it is annoying to me. They don't have the life experience that it usually takes (specifically hardships) to be singing about something that relates to them, and that isn't their fault.
American Idol Season 9 Quote

      
m