Anyway, Michael was remarkable and the rest of the dudes was a total scrubfest. Michael is probably the best one on the entire show and if he keeps giving performances like this he'll enter GOAT discussions.
Everyone else sucks though. Andrew is unlistenable.
And Tim, lol PEOPLE LIKED THIS?
Listen, I think all songs are fair game, but you really shouldn't touch a Leonard Cohen song with that much soul and depth if you're some 16 year old heartthrob kid. It's just nonsense. Castro did an admirable job with it, but that's just because he did it well vocally and even Castro probably didn't even know much of the song until someone told him to do because it suited his voice.
There's some songs teenager kids on Idol just shouldn't do. Hallelujah is absolutely one of them.
I mean,
REALLY TIM URBAN?!?!?! You REALLY think you can do this justice???
/rant