From reading both this and the Lost threads, I'd say that TheHip41 uses hyperbole in a great percentage of his posts. It makes it tough to take things he says seriously imo. Everytime he disagrees with someone its always "You're so bad at watching tv, I'm clearly 100% correct here!" If he would tone it down a bit, he'd be a much better poster imo because he does have good insight overall.
well, when it turns out that Shannon is Sayid's love of his life, I will gladly eat crow.
but it won't happen because I don't suck at watching Lost.
Just like in AI, if Casey somehow has an amazing vocal next week, I will be the first to say I'm wrong.
but I'm not wrong, because Casey is not capable of a great performance.
And when people around you are having moments and you are just above average every week, on Idol, that means you go home.
Do the judges know who is going home? It'd be kind of awkward if Michelle were still here next week with Kara deciding to rip her performance the next day. I don't get why they comment on something like that at all.