I really wonder how much freedom these kids have when it comes to song selection. I'm tired of sitting hearing watching these kids perform the whatever songs were overplayed the most over the last 2-3 years.

Wow....Lee Duhweezy sucked c***

Totally stunned by Simon's comments

I guess they forgot to pick people who know how to sing this year.

lol at making Chasing Cars a rock song

I knew bad things were happening when they picked room 3 over room 2

lol this

Mullet WTF. Had to have lost a bet. Man, some of the main contenders for the top 24 that are watching this and got cut have to be wondering WTF.

Seriously almost every performance so far this year has been LOLterrible.

Here goes

Todrick - Cool mix. This guy is rly good.
Aaron - Unfortunately he doesn't suck. We'll have to put up with him a long, long time.
Jermaine - This does not sound good at all. No mas.
Tim - Epic fail. Clear why he didn't make the top 24 the first time.
Joe - Nice tone. Sounds great. Best of the night so far. Wtf Simon talkin bout.
Tyler - Cheezy. Karaoke.

This is by far the most emotion Casey James has shown during a song. He's definitely worked on it. I don't really like how he cuts everything off, but he's been one of the best so far.

Way to steal Randy's joke Simon

LOL Simon just called Kara a cougar. Awesome.

Case - A+
John - A
Aaron - A-
Todrick - B+
Joe - B+
Michael - B
Andrew - C
Tyler - D
Alex - D
Jermaine - D-
Lee - F
Tim - F

All grades given before judge's comments

Garcia wins round 1 by default I guess.

Garcia is awful, I srsly wish he would die. I don't give a **** about his story, he looks like Gokey with Down's.

Tim and Alex should be sent home, no question

Garcia was weak. He's going to go far, but that was a dumb performance.

I'd say Tim for sure and then Alex or Tyler Grady

terrible, terrible night

I can see why Simon is leaving this show. This was an insufferable 2 days and there was not one memorable performance out of the entire batch.

Yeah, Tim and Alex.

Lee - Eh. We really don't need more singers who sound like this.
John - What a ****ing P-I-M-P. Ok lol he can't sing but epic intro.
Mike - The guys are TERRRRRRRRRRRRIBLE.
Alex - This season officially has no talent.
Casey - 100% chance he bones Kara. Oh and he's very, very good. AI10 winner here.
Andrew - He's alright.

Rankings:
1. Casey
----------
2. Joe
----------
3. Aaron
4. Todrick
----------
5. Lee
6. Andrew
7. Mike
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
8. Alex
9. Jermaine
10. John
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
----------
11. Tyler
12. Tim

The guys are AWFUL AWFUL AWFUL

Who is Tim?

Alex does have a pleasant sounding voice, but I don't see him getting over the nerves, lack of confidence, or inability to stay on track with his song. I'm not sure what his major malfunction is, but I don't see him getting over his issues any time soon.

Casey...mmmmmm.

I liked Aaron better than I expected. For some reason I was expecting him to be all high school musical or something. Does Simon confuse humility with lack of confidence?

I found Lee to be pleasantly surprising as well. When he made it through, I was like, who is this guy?

Can that 70's show even sing?

Oh yeah, I just remembered who Tim is. RJ from Prison Break, right?

that hailey vaughn chick has the best legs of any contestant in the last 5 years, on that alone she should go thru. that big upper lip is absolutely ridiculous but other than that she's smoking. what's strange is that her bottom lip is normal and almost luscious but her upper is coal black and looks like she just got smashed in the face. but got to love anyone with legs like that.

i told you guys that andrew garcia was a one trick pony.


lee dewyze is cream of men's crop

munoz can sing but he's blah

not sure what to think about that alex lambert dude,,,, his appearance tilts me.



Siobhan Magnus and crystal (nasty teeth) bowersox are awesome!

what was up with that ugly (but nice body) freak show lily scott and her put down of ryan seacrest. low class move making fun of his 5'8" height. hope she gets tossed for that. her mom was ugly as sin; that's who she takes after.

ashley rodriguez sucks so does janelle wheeler


KATIE STEVENS MAKES ME FURIOUS! I HATE HER FACE AND I HATE HER PERKY/SUPERCONFIDANT MANNER. SOMEONE TELL HER SHE'S UGLY