Quote:
Wow. I actually have to apologize for making a post as stupid as that. Must have been really tilted that she got knocked out, cause that post of mine makes no sense. Sorry about that.
What I meant to say was probably more like
"Ignoring personal preference, she has the biggest range of anybody ever on American Idol, and in my opinion, one of the best voices"
I wanted her to win really bad. I thought her high range was awesome.
She has projection problems in the low range and is nasally in the low to mid range. In the High range she is almost as good as Lambert.
I am saying this as a fan of hers. But, after many chances in the last few weeks she just proved she could sing a "whole" song.
She is not even close to being in the top 15 of all-time best voices on Idol. I was hoping she was the female version of Lambert, but no luck.
That said, she may have the most upside of all contestants this year if she can really work at her craft. Right now she is not that great.