Quote:
Originally Posted by mjw0586
That's a really bad analogy. If I only think Aaron's vocals are a little better than Casey's and Casey's a much better performer, then of course I'm going to want to see Casey.
My whole point was that Archuleta's vocals were far enough better than Cook's to make up for any gap in performing ability.
my point is you are underestimating how GOOD David Cook is vocally.
i agree DA is probably better as a pure singer, but Cook is really really good.
Aside from Clay and Reuben and DA, who on Idol has more pure singing ability than David Cook? I'm not saying they don't exist, I'm just asking who you think is a better singer? I'm talking about the males only.
Some of the notes he hits at the end of ABMB is similar to Siohban, but he hits then, and the whole song is on pitch, unlike simoan.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPT8gqmcqlk
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HiiVN...eature=related listen from 1:30 on, that guy can ****ing sing