^anyone can predict that bottom 3

tim should have gone home tho; too bad judges can't use save to bring back alex lambert

spot on imo . i thought they cut 2 each weak shame, woulda been good for my bets if two females got cut.

I haven't been looking at the betting lines but it has to be something better than even money that the final two are women, no? And something like 2:1 it's exactly Crystal and Shiobhan.

At this point it would be a near miracle is there was a guy in the final 3 imo.

It seems like the consensus for awhile has been

Siobhan
Crystal
Casey
Mike
Didi

With the contest being between Siobhan and Crystal.

I don't get why Didi is ranked so high. Actually, I do. She is hot. But, her singing style is annoying, and if Crytsal sang like that, Crystal would be ranked like 11th

Didi is getting too much love cause she's hot. Then again, I guess Casey is doing that for the girls - probalby getting too many votes because he's a good looking guy.

imo it would HAVE to be:
didi
crystal
shioban

keep in mind, as men get kicked off, the lone man starts getting some votes that other men would get. it might not be a huge, but it def factors in. i would say same applies for race, and style (like why country music singing styles fair well).

how does ygos apply here?

Casey is a better singer than Didi tho imo. Didi's voice is just weak and she has no range at all.

I think Didi and Casey are pretty good mirrors of each other. Both are above average at singing, but neither one is going to be wowing us or the judges, but they are pretty.

Its tough NOT to have Didi that high since everyone else is garbage compared to her.

You have Crystal/Simoan/Michael

next step, you have Didi/Casey/

Then ppl like Lee/Katie/Paige/Aaron

then garbage like Tim and Andrew left


Who are you going to put above Didi? Lee, maybe, Katie, no, Paige, no, Aaron, maybe, Tim and Andrew, no

so unless Didi forgets the words a lot, and Lee crushes it, Didi is top 5



here are my updated 1-11 finishers

Siobhan
Crystal
Casey
Didi
Michael
Lee
Katie
Aaron
Paige
Andrew
Tim

Good point!


As for my prediction of winner it goes:

Crystal (I know this is not the common opinion)
Siobhan
Didi
a bunch of other really terrible people, most of whom would not make top 24 any other season

Same but I switch Didi and Michael (for now) and yeah that's about it.

Crystal is a huge favorite.

Unfortunately, I think Big Mike will make top 3, maybe top 2. He just seems to have a big following with his story getting so much early air time. Plus, even when he sounds mediocre, the judges just drool over him.

:facepalm


siobhan kills her despite the ridiculous tats, nose ring, and crooked teeth.

siobhan is more my type, personally. she looked way hot last night.

ya, i don't think casey is better than the rest, but I feel he will get to #3

That could change if Michael keeps giving amazing performances.

michael sucks so overrated

besides that, he looks like a buffoon every time he moves.

for me, personally, dog, i'd marry Siobhan site unseen.

But, Didi is prettier.

Siobhan is cute and geeky, and that is what makes her attractive.

this is just wrong, he has the top two male performances of the season (once we got to live shows) His Stones song was decent, nothing crazy. Aside from Michael's two amazing vocals, the only songs I even remember are Aaron's from this week, and I hate to say it, Casey's version of Heaven, because even that wasn't even that good.

What other male has had a great vocal?

My scoreboard

Michael 2
Casey 0.5
the other 4 none

I thought Crystal, too. But after this week, I think it will depend on who wins the head-to-head battle between Crystal and Siobhan. Crystal is not going to do and "bad" performances, but will she get better? Will Siobhan pull off more songs like last week? I guess we'll see.

I think Casey or Mike will get in ahead of Didi. I don't really care who the third is after Crystal and Siobhan, but it may be a guy just based on the volume of women who vote.

I find Siohban the most attractive girl. Mostly because her voice is like Heaven's gift to mankind.

the men just suck, flat out.


no way is didi prettier than siobhan.

when siobhan is just standing there with her mouth closed and tats covered she is a 98 out of 100

didi is an 86 out of 100

plus didi looks like crap in jeans,,, seriously weird ass does she have

Oh, heh, those would by my rankings in terms of how much I like them. I think they will also finish in a similar manner. A bit different though. If I were to guess the order they stay...

Crystal
Siobhan
Casey
Michael
Katie
Lee
Didi
Aaron
Paige
Andrew
Tim

Michael will not have a career beyond that of a cruise ship entertainer. He is a decent singer but also cheezetastic.

Siobhan
Crystal
--------
Didi
Casey
--------






Michael
Paige
Katie
Aaron
--------






Tim

Siobhan has a lot of room to improve. She's pretty raw. I dunno how much the next few weeks can get her reaching anywhere near her ceiling--probably not--but all of her performances have been a bit messy in spots though it kinda makes me like it even more. Totally agree Crystal will not ever be "bad". She seems like a total pro who has put in a ton of hours. Very polished.

anyone want to give me odds on me picking the top 3 out of 4 guesses?

I'll pick:

Siobhan
Crystal
Casey
Didi

If 3 of them make the top 3, I win....I'll put up $100 against....

someone make me an offer!