Quote:
Originally Posted by SarcasticRat
Kelly Clarkson was def. better than Tamyra.
Don't get the talent has slipped argument, everyone on that season except Kelly and Tamyra was pretty awful and probably wouldn't get through hollywood week now.
I think s1 gets a pass since it wasn't huge yet.
What I think everyone is saying is the talent at the TOP isn't there this year.
s1 - kelly tamara
s2 - reuben, clay, kimberley locke
s3 - fantasia, Diana, Hudson, La toya
s4 - i personally haven't seen it, but Carrie seems like an obv choice
s5 - elliot, daughtry
s6 - shrek
for those saying this year's top 12 will be lol, check out s6's top 12
http://www.americanidol.com/archive/...tants/season6/
6 guys that are at varying degrees of suck, and 3 girls that can sing well. Jordin wins by default
s7- David A, David C, and even ppl like Michael and Brooke were solid
s8- Adam, Allison, Kris
s9 - ??
Right now, there are no guys that are on the level of David A(i h8 u) or David Cook, or Clay, or Reuben, or Adam.
For the girls, a few could be, just haven't done it yet.