well that why you gotta go in the AI gambling threads and get some bets so you have some horses to cheer for

Definitely not. He is the worst singer but has huge zach effron like appeal that crushes in the AI main voting demographic of young girls, I wouldn't be surprised if he stuck around for a few weeks just based on that.

Wrong.

There's usually more talent than this

i agree, but it's not THAT bad


it's not like everyone was Lacey bad. Everyone was solid on the girls side minus 2 or 3, just no one but Siobhan knocked it out.


If it's top 12 week, and we get 12 blah performances, then i'll agree with you.

cant believe Haeley made it. she was the worst. and i dont want to sound racist, but she has some big lips

whoa two of the prettiest girls got voted off ;/

Joe off and Tim stays? lololol

wtfwtfwtf how was Joe eliminated tonight??? damn mexicans forgot to call in for him

^ they obv voted for garcia

lol u make a good point there

the last 2 should've both been eliminated. but if i had to see 1 go before the other, im glad it was tyler

It's entirely possible that this voting was the worst I've ever seen, but let's be honest, America has been flat out ****ing awful at this for seven years now. What a complete and utter joke.

Urban was completely and utterly horrendous.
Alex Lambert was completely and utterly horrendous.
Lacey Brown was worse than Urban and Lambert combined.
Haley Vaughn was terribad and might be the least physically pleasing female to look at in the recorded history of life.
Munoz was solid, more than good enough to move on, somehow he didn't.
Grady was a decent choice to go home.

I still think keeping Nikki McKibbin over Tamyra Gray in the first season was the worst fans decision ever

wow i'm very surprised by the results. nobody i called to go home went home--my picks were tim, alex, haeley, and lacey. i'm glad to see tyler go away. i thought joe was good wtf. ashley and janell both had some potential i thought.

well at least this year is loaded with hotties. michelle, didi, katelyn, katie (chrishanson.jpg) all pretty hot. siobhan aint bad either.

Epic fail by America. Janell, Tyler, and Ashley didn't have amazing vocals this week but they were far from the worst, and all had the kind of personality and star power it takes to actually win. Now we're inexplicably stuck with people like Lacey and Alex who honestly have no chance in hell at actually winning this. FU.

I think Haeley's a bit better than people are saying. She wasn't good Tuesday, but she's got a good voice.

FYP

Tyler was incredibly bad.

really hope garcia and didi kill it next week...

and hopefully siobahn does something somewhat upbeat (like hollywood week performance that saved her)

so im going heads up fantasy style with a friend. i dont claim to be a knowledgeable idol judge or fan, but i got suckered into this anyway. here are my picks. feel free to critique.

24-21:
tim urban
jermaine sellers
lacey brown
paige miles
20-17:
tyler grady
alex lambert
ashley rodriguez
janell wheeler
16-13:
toddrick hall
john park
haeley vaughn
siobhan magnus
12-joe munoz
11-michael lynch
10-lilly scott
9-lee dewyze
8-katelyn epperly
7-aaron kelly
6-michelle delamor
5-katie stevens
4-andrew garcia
3-crystal bowersox
2-didi benami
1-casey james

the scoring works like so...
24 -- 0 pts
20 -- 2 pts
16 -- 3 pts
12 -- 5 pts
11 -- 6 pts
10 -- 8 pts
9 -- 10 pts
8 -- 12 pts
7 -- 14 pts
6 -- 16 pts
5 -- 18 pts
4 -- 20 pts
3 -- 22 pts
2 -- 25 pts
1 -- 30 pts

if casey wins, i get 30 pts, if he gets 2nd i get 25. if tim urban wins, i max out at 0. if toddrick gets 5th, i get 3 pts. etc etc

what are you guys freaking out about, there were no shockers tonight.

Basically, Haeley and Tim and Lacey should be gone, but they aren't.

You are making it sound like Joe was the next Michael Jackson, and he's terrible too.


Joe has 0% chance of winning, ldo, but I meant before he even sang. He has no charisma, nothing, just an average to above average voice.


As far as the girls, Janell is awful, and Ashley was ok, but ok isn't good enough with the girls this year.



I have a feeling Tim and Lacey and all of them will be gone before top 12 anyway.


Kris Allen: let it be done, amirite?

Rat, watch Tyler's top 12 performance on youtube. He doesn't even sing the song.


Basically, 6-9 people should have gone home today, but only 4 can. We get 4 more scrubs gone next week, and it won't be until top 16, when two girls go home, that it starts getting tough, because the top 8 girls are going to be solid

JOE MUNOZ HAD A GREAT VOICE!!!!!!!!!!!!!


HE JUST LACKED STAR APPEAL

racist ban!







haley is hot as hell except for that big coal black upper lip.

I know Tyler's vocals sucked... so did like 9/12 of the guys. At least he had some kind of personality or style thing going and thus had more than a snowball's chance in hell at winning, which is more than I can say for some of the ones still left.