Quote:
Originally Posted by areaman
the reason why rodgers fell was because there werent any other teams that needed qbs that year.
i think smith was rushed, and its kind of sad..thats what happens tho when qbs are rushed into the nfl into really crappy spots. go down the list of teams that drafted qbs early and they became busts because the team has greater needs than qbs. its a long list..
however rodgers would also be successful anywhere he went, you can tell by his attitude. you might be right, he might have gotten killed behind the 9ers o-lines and other stuff like poor coaching, i dont really know, but that would be his only setback. but he would do everything in his powers to become a success in the nfl tho and eventually get there.
there are 2 people in wisconsin sports right now with attitudes bigger than the state, and you can tell they are both going to be great because they will do everything in their powers to get there. rodgers is one of them, the other is ryan braun. they both want to be legends.
Who knows. Rodgers also has the best receiving core in the league and a team that was geared for him to succeed. The only issue now is protection. I bet you, like most QBs, he would have failed in bad situations. If he came to the 9ers he would have failed. He probably would have failed going to the Raiders and a handful of other teams. He went into a great situation. He got to sit out 2 seasons and learn from a good HC who was focused on QBs. He dind't really get to know, but he got to watch Favre. He got Jennings, Driver, and others. Who knows if Rodgers would have succeeded elsewhere but it's pretty nieve to think he would have succeeded anywhere he went, your first job usually isn't as easy one as an NFL QB, but he got a much easier job than Smith got.
Smith was bound to fail. Spread QB, thrown into a fire mess his first year, had 3 different OCs and no protection and really no weapons other than Frank Gore for most of his tenure. The only difference is Rodgers wasn't a spread QB, but I doubt he succeeds under the same pressure that Smith was put under.
I don't even know what to say about Braun, but lol.