Quote:
Originally Posted by shane88888
Tomlin needs to sit the **** down and reassess his in-game decisions. His endgame strategy has managed to get worse. This seat-of-the-pants decision **** is completely unacceptable.
1. Tomlin
The Rooneys need to send Tomlin to CMU this summer to enroll in a Game Theory class. Tomlin made more than a few AWFUL choices this season. And what's worse, he doesn't realize it. He thinks that a coach has to make tough decisions (read: no right or wrong answer) and will inevitably absorb criticism regardless of the choice he makes. It's not just Tomlin either. All around the league coaches make strategically incorrect decisions all the time. Not decisions that are a little risky, or a little conservative, but decisions that are flat out WRONG. When to go for two. When to punt or grunt. That kind of thing. Coaches like Tomlin ROUTINELY make choices like these that are demonstrably WRONG. What is startling is that this is acceptable to the owners who pay them millions of dollars.
Being an NFL head coach requires a man to wear A LOT of hats. You're the manager of over 100 men between players, coaches and staff. You have a hand in building the roster. You have a hand in teaching the players. You have a hand in developing game plans. And you lay out the vision that governs it all. It's understandable that the guys who are most fit to handle such a job are not ALSO the best at logic puzzles. But what is NOT understandable or acceptable is sitting back and allowing them to make a mess of the simple, strategic decisions that arise week in and week out. All teams should hire an "assistant coach of strategic decision-making". But until they do, the Rooneys have GOT to impress upon Tomlin the need to get these decisions right. Not everything is a gut call, like whether to pull a struggling quarterback.
Tomlin gets second guessed, like all coaches. And somewhere along the line I'm sure he was taught by a mentor that you've just gotta ignore those criticisms. So when a reporter who never played the game questions kicking the PAT late in the San Diego game, he threw out some random explanation and moved on. But it's NOT ok to kick the PAT when you're down 18 with a handful of minutes to go, and nothing you say to justify it can make it ok. The front office has to review with him the various moments at which he indisputably harmed the team's chances through his own short-comings in the area of game theory. And then they need to work together to make sure it doesn't happen to such a flagrant degree again next season.