Quote:
Originally Posted by JBurdan
As much as I love Halladay I don't wanna give up our entire farm system, Halladay doesn't give us a world series title 100%, sure he helps alot but say we don't win a world series in the next 2 seasons, he walks after that cause no way they re-sign him we are left with no titles and no farm system. There is gonna be some arms out there that are pitching pretty well this year that we won't need to give up nearly as much as halladay. Plus if we do get halladay we're not gonna be able to spend any money in the off-season with his $20 million next year.
What do you propose they do then, stand pat? OBV getting Halladay is not a 100% lock to win another championship, nobody is, but he is about as close as your gonna get to that. Even if we dont win a WS in these next 2 season without him, oh well we took our shot and didnt make it, nobody would fault the Phillies for that.
He isnt a rent a player for 2 months like Sabathia was last year. You would get one of the best pitchers in baseball for a yr and a half, why wouldnt you want to do that? And to argue the point further, if we dont re-sign him we will get 2 1st rd picks back since he will be a type A free agent. So you can replenish your farm system on the back-end. And BTW Howard, Hamels and company might not be here in 3 years, so there is a window of opportunity.
I dont want Pedro either.