Quote:
Originally Posted by Pippen33
Baaaaaahahahahhahahaha Like that could ever happen
- 11 mins left 4th Q. Let's go for it on 4th and 1 from the 46 instead of pinning them deep. By "them" I mean a Giants offense that basically did nothing in Q's 2 and 3 (and their first pos of the 4th was a 3 and out). Their 2 TDs (both in Q1) were a blown coverage by Matthews (shocking!!) and a 6 yard pass that (3 missed tackles later) turned into a 74 yard TD. Let's give a struggling team life by giving them the ball just short of mid-field.
I had mixed feelings on the decision to go for it before the snap. What ultimately made me think punting was better was that we had just gotten stuffed 4 times on the goalline because our offensive line was getting manhandled. Plus we were only up by 2, so not converting almost assuredly gives the Giants the lead.
Pretty sure this play occured after Vick's hand injury which makes it even more LOL.
Quote:
- 1st and goal at the Giants 2. On two of the next 3 plays he called for an Owen Schmidt run.
This one blew my mind. We don't give the ball to McCoy, who had completely demoralized the Giants defense all game long, or Brown, who presumably was brought in for just these kinds of situations. Instead we try two QB sneaks with a banged up Vick and two runs with the FB. I'll never, ever understand what they were thinking there. Ever.
Quote:
At this point, what else can be said about the LBs and S's? I love our front 4 and our CBs....and our defense is still beyond terrible as a whole.
I said this in the BEAST thread, but offensive coordinators are too smart to stack up on one or two positions like the Eagles have. Another thing that defies logic is spending two or three times as much on your backup QB as your entire starting LB core. Then there's the fact that we've drafted safeties highly over the last two years and neither have made an impact whatsoever, and as result we have easily the worst safety tandem in the league.
I mean, how is Jarret not even contributing on special teams? Isn't the book on him that he is a hard nosed physical safety? He can't go out on kickoffs and knock some people around? Ridiculous.
In fact, the only impact we've gotten in the last two years from a 4th round pick or higher is Casey Matthews. LOL