Quote:
Originally Posted by DVaut1
This isn't so much the 2p2 opinion as it is the general Michigan internet fan opinion:
- Obviously getting a Year 3. Some people think next year is his do-or-die, > 8 wins or more or fired type season. I just made a post in the perma-thread where I think he gets a Year 4 unless we miss another bowl game. This is probably the minority position. Most people think he has to get it done next year, where "get it done" = 8 or 9 wins or more. I think he has a longer leash because the school is conservative and won't want to rebuild again.
- Most people think the offense is progressing just fine. Everyone agrees the defense is just terrible. There is division as to whether or not there is any hope the defense can become competent enough to not lose 5 game a season. If you have no hope, you want RR fired now or are very cynical about the future, and you think RR is to blame for focusing solely on the offense and ignoring the defense, for not treating defensive recruiting with the requisite seriousness, for cycling through two D-coordinators in two years and staying loyal to incompetent position coaches on defense like LB coach Jay Hopson, who's an old tag-along-wherever-he-goes of RR's. The LBs have been especially, inexplicably bad this season.
If you have hope, you just want this season to end, and think all the criticism of RR's treatment of the defense listed above are overstated, and the team is just too young, there's been too much attrition, and doesn't have enough bodies to seriously compete, and that with time we'll be better.
- As for potential replacements, there's a general division between hoping we could get Les Miles somehow (kind of like ND's perpetual hard-on for Urban Meyer, with the key difference than Urban Meyer is actually a good coach), Brian Kelly, and Jim Harbaugh. No one seems to think Kelly will be around if/when RR gets fired. No one is really talking seriously about it because any coaching search is at least a year off.
Hopson never coached with Rich Rod before Michigan.
/nit
The defense isn't going to magically get better with a new coach. Michigan ranked 7th in the Big Ten last year in terms of players drafted to the NFL. This year we have Brandon Graham and ???? Next year Donovan Warren and ??? That's not just defense, but the entire team. We have one safety on scholarship who is not a freshman, starting two walk-ons, using 70 of 85 scholarships, etc. Also, the numbers do not show that Rod is neglecting defensive recruiting and the charge that he is somehow an offensive coach who cares nothing about defense is unfounded. He had several excellent defenses at WVU. They ranked 8th and 6th nationally in yards allowed and points allowed, respectively, at the end of his final season there.
That's the POV in a nutshell of rational fans who understand why this is taking some time.
I don't remember how ND handled the Davie and Willingham firings? If this is going to happen will it happen soon or what?