Quote:
Originally Posted by THAKID
Gardner in left sounds horrible... Gardner in CF against LHP and pinch hit for later is cool... He shouldn't be better than a 4th OF for the Yankees... He's just not a major leauge level hitter
He hasn't been a Major League hitter, but when you combine what he does at the plate, with his stolen bases and excellent fielding, his overall contribution to the team makes him a fine player.
He was a more valuable player than Melky last year in way less time.
EDIT: Actually he was a league average hitter last year so I'm not even sure your claim of "he's not a major league hitter" is even correct. I have no problem with him playing full-time in this lineup.