Quote:
Originally Posted by DeadCellKid
Agame ITT... +1
Bay could come back and have a monster year... Who knows.. Do I like the signing? Jury still out on that too, but he's still top 15-20 in the game for his position... Lineup for next year?
Reyes
Pagan
Beltran
Bay
Wright
Davis
Thole
Murphy/2bPitcher
Thoughts?
i really really hope not. i know this will sound nuts, but if you really think about it, murphy cannot hit a lick, and his fielding is also very sub par. if you plan on putting him at second and cutting castillo and eating the money, you mite as well just keep castillo at second, because honestly do you really get that much more out of murphy than you would out of castillo.
i know people will aruge murhpy has more potential wich he obv does but castillo will hit 275+ get on base and even tho hes gotten old and lost some range still probably has more than murphy.
now dont get me wrong im not saying castillo for starting 2b, im just saying if the plan is to get rid of louis and start murphy at second why not just keep castillo...anyone agree? and if not tell me why