Quote:
Originally Posted by Goodie
So, you think he makes personnel decisions that he couldn't explain to you and you would think it makes sense, every single time?
That seems crazy to me.
No, Im not getting drawn into this any more. Agree to disagree. Onto the other extreme.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Salva135
Sums it up right there. "I trust BB to let Brady walk tomorrow" Edelman is iintegral, keep drinking the kool aid to think he's not impoirtant.
Who said he wasn't important? He's been super important to this year's team. I wish he had been locked up for multiple years earlier. He knows the offense, has been productive, and is awesome as a punt returner.
That said, there's a salary cap, and blindly paying the asking price of every important player is how you get to Jetstown or Redskinland. There's a pretty duplicative player on the roster that isnt getting cut this offseason, that's a factor. There are two other rookie receivers who have been productive this season and are likely to see their roles increase, that's a factor. There are other, more physically gifted WR's potentially available, that's a factor.
So what would you be willing to pay Edelman? 3/30 with $10MM guaranteed? 5/40 with 20 guaranteed? 6/66 with $30MM guaranteed? Just hand him a blank check and say fill it out as you'd like? If you had to lose one of Solder/McCourty/Edelman, who would it be? You havent been happy with the defense for years, are you going to be happy not having any money to shore it up this offseason? The DT position needs a huge restructure. Wendell has to be extended or they have to find another Center and Connolly is probably gone as well (or he needs an extension). The whole running back core turns over next year, do you want to extend Vereen?
Its pretty close to meaningless to say "OMG WE HAVE TO SIGN TEH EDELMAN OR ELSE THE FRONT OFFICE IS TEH STUPID!!11!1" without knowing what he will command on the open market or what else the team does with the money.
Personally, Im hoping the market views him as a system player and the Pats can get him for something like 3/12 with some guaranteed money.
If he's going to get paid like an elite WR, thanks for the contributions Julian. Sign me up for Amendola/Dobson/Thompkins/Boyce and another draft pick or cheaper WR rather than burning $6-$8MM of cap space on Edelman. That passing offense will be just fine.